《中国工程科学》 >> 2023年 第25卷 第2期 doi: 10.15302/J-SSCAE-2023.02.011
面向高比例可再生能源消纳的电力市场建设及研究进展
下一篇 上一篇
摘要
完善的电力市场可在电力资源配置方面发挥决定性作用,是保证各类市场主体开展活跃的供需互动、促进可再生能源消纳的关键机制;针对性开展电力市场中影响可再生能源消纳因素的综合性分析,也是相关应用研究亟需。本文重点考虑全时间尺度下促进可再生能源消纳相关的交易机制,概述了国外典型电力市场结构及运行情况,梳理了相应电力市场结构及机制中促进可再生能源消纳的关键影响因素;围绕可再生能源消纳的多维关键影响因素,深入分析了我国各类市场结构和不同机制的建设现状,归纳出促进可再生能源消纳电力市场建设面临的挑战。从电力市场与碳市场、绿证市场耦合机制,可再生能源参与的中长期、现货交易及其衔接机制,面向高比例可再生能源的辅助服务市场,面向高比例可再生能源消纳的需求侧响应机制等方面,梳理了我国相关电力市场的学术研究进展。研究建议,实施多市场协同运作、中长期及现货交易衔接、辅助服务市场建设、需求响应机制建设等重点举措,支持面向高比例可再生能源消纳的电力市场建设。
参考文献
[ 1 ] International Renewable Energy Agency. Renewable capacity statistics 2022 [R]. Abu Dhabi: International Renewable Energy Agency, 2022.
[ 2 ]
肖云鹏 , 王锡凡 , 王秀丽 , 等 . 面向高比例可再生能源的电力市场研究综述 [J]. 中国电机工程学报 , 2018 , 38 3 : 663 ‒ 674 .
Xiao Y P , Wang X F , Wang X L , al e t . Review on electricity market towards high proportion of renewable energy [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE , 2018 , 38 3 : 663 ‒ 674 .
[ 3 ]
张勇军 , 羿应棋 , 李立浧 , 等 . 双碳目标驱动的新型低压配电系统技术展望 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2022 , 46 22 : 1 ‒ 12 .
Zhang Y J , Yi Y Q , Li L C , al e t . Prospect of new low-voltage distribution system technology driven by carbon emission peak and carbon neutrality targets [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2022 , 46 22 : 1 ‒ 12 .
[ 4 ]
谢开 . 美国电力市场运行与监管实例分析 [M]. 北京 : 中国电力出版社 , 2017 .
Xie K . Electricity market, operation and regulation: US practice [M]. Beijing : China Electric Power Press , 2017 .
[ 5 ]
舒印彪 , 张智刚 , 郭剑波 , 等 . 新能源消纳关键因素分析及解决措施研究 [J]. 中国电机工程学报 , 2017 , 37 1 : 1 ‒ 9 .
Shu Y B , Zhang Z G , Guo J B , al e t . Study on key factors and solution of renewable energy accommodation [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE , 2017 , 37 1 : 1 ‒ 9 .
[ 6 ]
孙大雁 , 关立 , 黄国栋 , 等 . 跨区域省间富余可再生能源电力现货交易的实践和思考 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2022 , 46 5 : 1 ‒ 10 .
Sun D Y , Guan L , Huan G D , al e t . Practice and reflection on trans-regional and cross-provincial electricity spot trading for surplus renewable energy [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2022 , 46 5 : 1 ‒ 10 .
[ 7 ]
丁一 , 谢开 , 庞博 , 等 . 中国特色、全国统一的电力市场关键问题研究1: 国外市场启示、比对与建议 [J]. 电网技术 , 2020 , 44 7 : 2401 ‒ 2410 .
Ding Y , Xie K , Pang B , al e t . Key issues of national unified electricity market with Chinese characteristics 1: Enlightenment, comparison and suggestions from foreign countries [J]. Power System Technology , 2020 , 44 7 : 2401 ‒ 2410 .
[ 8 ] Stekli J, Bai L Q, Cali U, al et. Distributed energy resource participation in electricity markets: A review of approaches, modeling, and enabling information and communication technologies [J]. Energy Strategy Reviews, 2022, 43: 100940.
[ 9 ] Gunarathna C L, Yang R J, Jayasuriya S, al et. Reviewing global peer-to-peer distributed renewable energy trading projects [J]. Energy Research & Social Science, 2022, 89: 102655.
[10] Ang T Z, Salem M, Kamarol M, al et. A comprehensive study of renewable energy sources: Classifications, challenges and suggestions [J]. Energy Strategy Reviews, 2022, 43: 100939.
[11] González D M L, G Rendon J. Opportunities and challenges of mainstreaming distributed energy resources towards the transition to more efficient and resilient energy markets [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2022, 157: 112018.
[12] Azarpour A, Mohammadzadeh O, Rezaei N, al et. Current status and future prospects of renewable and sustainable energy in North America: Progress and challenges [J]. Energy Conversion and Management, 2022, 269: 115945.
[13] Dey S, Sreenivasulu A, Veerendra G T N, al et. Renewable energy present status and future potentials in India: An overview [J]. Innovation and Green Development, 2022, 1(1): 100006.
[14] Aboagye B, Gyamfi S, Ofosu E A, al et. Status of renewable energy resources for electricity supply in Ghana [J]. Scientific African, 2021, 11: e00660.
[15] Liu J Q, Wang J H, Cardinal J. Evolution and reform of UK electricity market [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2022, 161: 112317.
[16]
樊宇琦 , 丁涛 , 孙瑜歌 , 等 . 国内外促进可再生能源消纳的电力现货市场发展综述与思考 [J]. 中国电机工程学报 , 2021 , 41 5 : 1729 ‒ 1752 .
Fan Y Q , Ding T , Sun Y G , al e t . Review and cogitation for worldwide spot market development to promote renewable energy accommodation [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE , 2021 , 41 5 : 1729 ‒ 1752 .
[17]
孙莹 , 李晓鹏 , 蔡文斌 , 等 . 面向新能源消纳的调峰辅助服务市场研究综述 [J]. 现代电力 , 2022 , 39 6 : 668 ‒ 676 .
Sun Y , Li X P , Cai W B , al e t . A research overview on ancillary services market of peak regulation [J]. Modern Electric Power , 2022 , 39 6 : 668 ‒ 676 .
[18]
丁峰 , 李晓刚 , 梁泽琪 , 等 . 国外可再生能源发展经验及其对我国相关扶持政策的启示 [J]. 电力建设 , 2022 , 43 9 : 1 ‒ 11 .
Ding F , Li X G , Liang Z Q , al e t . Review of foreign experience in promoting renewable energy development and inspiration to China [J]. Electric Power Construction , 2022 , 43 9 : 1 ‒ 11 .
[19]
赵勇强 . 新能源电力市场化交易的国际经验与中国实施路径探讨 [J]. 价格理论与实践 , 2019 10 : 9 ‒ 13 .
Zhao Y Q . Discussion on international experience of new energy electricity marketization and China´s implementation path [J]. Price: Theory Practice , 2019 10 : 9 ‒ 13 .
[20] Hafner M, Tagliapietra S. The geopolitics of the global energy transition [M]. Cham: Springer, 2020.
[21] Fatras N, Ma X, Duan H B, al et. A systematic review of electricity market liberalisation and its alignment with industrial consumer participation: A comparison between the Nordics and China [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2022, 167: 112793.
[22]
包铭磊 , 丁一 , 邵常政 , 等 . 北欧电力市场评述及对我国的经验借鉴 [J]. 中国电机工程学报 , 2017 , 37 17 : 4881 ‒ 4892 .
Bao M L , Ding Y , Shao C Z , al e t . Review of nordic electricity market and its suggestions for China [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE , 2017 , 37 17 : 4881 ‒ 4892 .
[23]
陈启鑫 , 房曦晨 , 郭鸿业 , 等 . 电力现货市场建设进展与关键问题 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2021 , 45 6 : 1 ‒ 15 .
Chen Q X , Fan X C , Guo H Y , al e t . Progress and key issues for construction of electricity spot market [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2021 , 45 6 : 1 ‒ 15 .
[24] Rancilio G, Rossi A, Falabretti D, al et. Ancillary services markets in Europe: Evolution and regulatory trade-offs [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2022, 154: 111850.
[25]
袁家海 , 席星璇 . 我国电力辅助服务市场建设的现状与问题 [J]. 中国电力企业管理 , 2020 7 : 34 ‒ 38 .
Yuan J H , Xi X X . Current situation and problem of Chinese electric power auxiliary service market construction [J]. China Power Enterprise Management , 2020 7 : 34 ‒ 38 .
[26]
孙莹 , 李晓鹏 , 蔡文斌 , 等 . 面向新能源消纳的调峰辅助服务市场研究综述 [J]. 现代电力 , 2022 , 39 6 : 668 ‒ 676 .
Sun Y , Li X P , Cai W B , al e t . A research overview on ancillary services market of peak regulation oriented to accommodation of new energy [J]. Modern Electric Power , 2022 , 39 6 : 668 ‒ 676 .
[27]
吴珊 , 边晓燕 , 张菁娴 , 等 . 面向新型电力系统灵活性提升的国内外辅助服务市场研究综述 [EBOL]. 2021-10-29 [ 2022-03-08 ]. https:doi.org10.19595j.cnki.1000-6753.tces.211730 .
Wu S , Bian X Y , Zhang J X , al e t . A review of domestic and foreign ancillary services market for improving flexibility of new power system [EBOL]. 2021-10-29 [ 2022-03-08 ]. https:doi.org10.19595j.cnki.1000-6753.tces.211730 .
链接1
[28]
叶文圣 , 荆朝霞 , 禤宗衡 . 英国频率响应服务市场及对我国调频市场建设的启示 [J]. 中国电力 , 2023 , 56 1 : 77 ‒ 86 .
Ye W S , Jing Z X , Xuan Z H . UK frequency response service markets and their implications for China´s frequency regulation market construction [J]. China Power , 2023 , 56 1 : 77 ‒ 86 .
[29]
代心芸 , 陈皓勇 , 肖东亮 , 等 . 电力市场环境下工业需求响应技术的应用与研究综述 [J]. 电网技术 , 2022 , 46 11 : 4169 ‒ 4186 .
Dai X Y , Chen H Y , Xiao D L , al e t . Review of applications and researches of industrial demand response technology under electricity market environment [J]. Power System Technology , 2022 , 46 11 : 4169 ‒ 4186 .
[30] Abedrabboh K, Al-Fagih L. Applications of mechanism design in market-based demand-side management: A review [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2023, 171: 113016.
[31]
王彩霞 , 时智勇 , 梁志峰 , 等 . 新能源为主体电力系统的需求侧资源利用关键技术及展望 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2021 , 45 16 : 37 ‒ 48 .
Wang C X , Shi Z Y , Liang Z F , al e t . Key technologies and prospects of demand-side resource utilization for power systems dominated by renewable energy [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2021 , 45 16 : 37 ‒ 48 .
[32] Shang N, Ding Y, Cui W Q. Review of market power assessment and mitigation in reshaping of power systems [J]. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy, 2022, 10(5): 1067‒1084.
[33] Buchholz W, Dippl L, Eichenseer M. Subsidizing renewables as part of taking leadership in international climate policy: The German case [J]. Energy Policy, 2019, 129: 765‒773.
[34] Ogunrinde O, Shittu E, Dhanda K. Investing in renewable energy: Reconciling regional policy with renewable energy growth [J]. IEEE Engineering Management Review, 2018, 46(4): 103‒111.
[35] Valenzuela J M, Rhys J. In plain sight: The rise of state coordination and fall of liberalised markets in the United Kingdom power sector [J]. Energy Research & Social Science, 2022, 94: 102882.
[36]
尚楠 , 陈政 , 卢治霖 , 等 . 电力市场、碳市场及绿证市场互动机理及协调机制 [J]. 电网技术 , 2023 , 47 1 : 142 ‒ 154 .
Shang N , Chen Z , Lu Z L , et al . Interaction principle and cohesive mechanism of electricity market, carbon market and grean power certificate market [J]. Power System Technology , 2023 , 47 1 : 142 ‒ 154 .
[37] Zhang F, Li Y, Li F L, al et. Decision-making behavior of power suppliers in the green certificate market: A system dynamics analysis [J]. Energy Policy, 2022, 171: 113296.
[38] Rannou Y, Boutabba M A, Barneto P. Are green bond and carbon markets in Europe complements or substitutes? Insights from the activity of power firms [J]. Energy Economics, 2021, 104: 105651.
[39]
张显 , 史连军 . 中国电力市场未来研究方向及关键技术 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2020 , 44 16 : 1 ‒ 11 .
Zhang X , Shi L J . Future research areas and key technologies of electricity market in China [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2020 , 44 16 : 1 ‒ 11 .
[40]
刘昊 , 郭烨 , 孙宏斌 . 中国跨区跨省电力交易综述及展望 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2022 , 46 15 : 187 ‒ 199 .
Liu H , Guo Y , Sun H B . Review and prospect of inter-regional and inter-provincial power trading in China [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2022 , 46 15 : 187 ‒ 199 .
[41]
孙大雁 , 关立 , 胡晨旭 , 等 . 省间电力现货交易机制设计与探索 [J]. 电网技术 , 2022 , 46 2 : 421 ‒ 428 .
Sun D Y , Guan L , Hu C X , al e t . Design and exploration of inter-provincial power spot trading mechanism [J]. Power System Technology , 2022 , 46 2 : 421 ‒ 429 .
[42] Hu B, Zhou P. Can the renewable power consumption guarantee mechanism help activate China´s power trading market [J]. Energy, 2022, 253: 124182.
[43]
王小昂 , 邹鹏 , 任远 , 等 . 山西电力现货市场中长期与现货衔接问题及对策 [J]. 电网技术 , 2022 , 46 1 : 20 ‒ 27 .
Wang X A , Zou P , Ren Y , al e t . Problems and solutions of medium long-term trading connected with electricity spot market in Shanxi Province [J]. Power System Technology , 2022 , 46 1 : 20 ‒ 27 .
[44]
曾鸣 , 许彦斌 , 马嘉欣 , 等 . " 绿证交易+配额制考核"对责任主体交易策略影响研究 [EBOL]. 2022-10-05 [ 2022-10-28 ]. https:kns.cnki.netkcmsdetail13.1212.TM.20221028.1119.002.html .
Zeng M , Xu Y B , Ma J X , al e t . Research on impact of "tradable green certificate trading+renewable portfolio standard assessment" on trading strategy of responsible subjects [EBOL]. 2022-10-05 [ 2022-10-28 ]. https:kns.cnki.netkcmsdetail13.1212.TM.20221028.1119.002.html .
链接1
[45]
汪鹏 , 宋晓华 , 杨昊雯 , 等 . 新配额制下电力 ‒ 绿证 ‒ 超额消纳量多尺度市场交易仿真 [J]. 系统仿真学报 , 2022 , 34 11 : 2458 ‒ 2469 .
Wang P , Song X H , Yang H W , al e t . Multi-market coupling trading simulation of electricity green certificate and excess consumption under new renewable portfolio standard [J]. Journal of System Simulation , 2022 , 34 11 : 2458 ‒ 2469 .
[46]
冯昌森 , 谢方锐 , 文福拴 , 等 . 基于智能合约的绿证和碳联合交易市场的设计与实现 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2021 , 45 23 : 1 ‒ 11 .
Feng C S , Xie F R , Wen F S , al e t . Design and implementation of joint trading market for green power certificate and carbon based on smart contract [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2021 , 45 23 : 1 ‒ 11 .
[47]
杨雪 , 金孝俊 , 王海洋 , 等 . 基于区块链的绿证和碳交易市场联合激励机制 [J]. 电力建设 , 2022 , 43 6 : 24 ‒ 33 .
Yang X , Jin X J , Wang H Y , al e t . Blockchain-based joint incentive mechanism for tradable green certificate and carbon trading market [J]. Electric Power Construction , 2022 , 43 6 : 24 ‒ 33 .
[48]
彭文兵 , 黄书旭 , 张潮 . 电力"现货+中长期"市场交易下不平衡电量分摊机制优化研究——考量将电力交易价格纳入分摊方法的分析 [J]. 价格理论与实践 , 2020 12 : 144 ‒ 147 .
Peng W B , Huang S X , Zhang C . Study on the optimization of unbalanced electricity allocation mechanism under the "spot + medium and long term" electricity market transaction—Considering the analysis of electricity transaction price into the allocation method [J]. Price: Theory Practice , 2020 12 : 144 ‒ 147 .
[49]
程松 , 周鑫 , 任景 , 等 . 面向多级市场出清的负荷聚合商联合交易策略 [J]. 电力系统保护与控制 , 2022 , 50 20 : 158 ‒ 167 .
Cheng S , Zhou X , Ren J , al e t . Bidding strategy for load aggregators in a multi-stage electricity market [J]. Power System Protection and Control , 2022 , 50 20 : 158 ‒ 167 .
[50]
孟繁林 , 钟海旺 , 夏清 . 基于非凸报价的高比例新能源现货市场机制 [J]. 电网技术 , 2023 , 47 1 : 120 ‒ 128 .
Meng F L , Zhong H W , Xia Q . Non-convex bidding-based spot market mechanism of high penetration renewable energy [J]. Power System Technology , 2023 , 47 1 : 120 ‒ 128 .
[51]
朱军飞 , 李京 , 李辉 , 等 . 计及期权合约和交易路径的省间优化出清模型与算法研究 [J]. 智慧电力 , 2022 , 50 7 : 89 ‒ 95 .
Zhu J F , Li J , Li H , al e t . Inter-provincial optimization clearing model and algorithm considering option contract and trading path [J]. Smart Power , 2022 , 50 7 : 89 ‒ 95 .
[52]
刘敦楠 , 李竹 , 董治新 , 等 . 基于标准能量块合约的电力中长期市场连续运营方案设计 [J]. 电网技术 , 2023 , 47 1 : 129 ‒ 144 .
Liu D N , Li Z , Dong Z X , al e t . Design of continuous operation scheme of electric power medium and long-term market based on standard energy block contracts [J]. Power System Technology , 2023 , 47 1 : 129 ‒ 144 .
[53]
李国庆 , 闫克非 , 范高锋 , 等 . 储能参与现货电能量 ‒ 调频辅助服务市场的交易决策研究 [J]. 电力系统保护与控制 , 2022 , 50 17 : 45 ‒ 54 .
Li G Q , Yan K F , Fan G F , al e t . Transaction decision-making of energy storage stations participating in the spot energy and frequency modulation ancillary service market [J]. Power System Protection and Control , 2022 , 50 17 : 45 ‒ 54 .
[54]
高爽 , 戴如鑫 . 电动汽车集群参与调频辅助服务市场的充电调控策略 [EBOL]. 2021-11-07 [ 2022-08-30 ]. https:kns.cnki.netkcmsdetail32.1180.TP.20220829.1653.008.html .
Gao S , Dai R X . Charging control strategy for electric vehicle cluster participating in frequency regulation ancillary service market [EBOL]. 2021-11-07 [ 2022-08-30 ]. https:kns.cnki.netkcmsdetail32.1180.TP.20220829.1653.008.html .
链接1
[55]
林阿竹 , 柯清辉 , 江岳文 . 独立储能参与调频辅助服务市场机制设计 [J]. 电力自动化设备 , 2022 , 42 12 : 26 ‒ 34 .
Lin A Z , Ke Q H , Jiang Y W . Market mechanism design of independent energy storage participating in frequency modulation auxiliary service market [J]. Electric Power Automation Equipment , 2022 , 42 12 : 26 ‒ 34 .
[56]
刘硕 , 张梦晗 , 夏清 , 等 . 基于备用辅助服务需求申报的现货市场机制设计 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2022 , 46 22 : 72 ‒ 82 .
Liu S , Zhang M H , Xia Q , al e t . Design of spot market mechanism based on demand bidding of reserve ancillary service [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2022 , 46 22 : 72 ‒ 82 .
[57]
刘学 , 刘硕 , 于松泰 , 等 . 面向新型电力系统灵活性提升的调峰容量补偿机制设计 [J]. 电网技术 , 2023 , 47 1 : 155 ‒ 163 .
Liu X , Liu S , Yu S T , al e t . Design of peak load regulation capacity compensation mechanism for new power system flexibility enhancement [J]. Power Grid Technology , 2023 , 47 1 : 155 ‒ 163 .
[58]
李振坤 , 魏砚军 , 张智泉 , 等 . 有源配电网黑启动恢复供电辅助服务市场机制研究 [J]. 中国电机工程学报 , 2022 , 42 18 : 6641 ‒ 6654 .
Li Z K , Wei Y J , Zhang Z Q , al e t . Research on market mechanism of black start restoration auxilliary service in distribution network [J]. Proceedings of the CSEE , 2022 , 42 18 : 6641 ‒ 6654 .
[59] Sreekumar S, Yamujala S, Sharma K C, al et. Flexible ramp products: A solution to enhance power system flexibility [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2022, 162: 112429.
[60]
刘敦楠 , 李竹 , 徐尔丰 , 等 . 面向新型电力系统的灵活能量块交易出清模型 [J]. 电网技术 , 2022 , 46 11 : 4150 ‒ 4162 .
Liu D N , Li Z , Xu E F , al e t . Flexible block order trading clearing model for new power systems [J]. Power System Technology , 2022 , 46 11 : 4150 ‒ 4162 .
[61]
王宣元 , 刘蓁 . 虚拟电厂参与电网调控与市场运营的发展与实践 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2022 , 46 18 : 158 ‒ 168 .
Wang X Y , Liu Z . Development and practice of virtual power plant participating in power grid regulation and market operation [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2022 , 46 18 : 158 ‒ 168 .
[62]
高洪超 , 陈启鑫 , 金泰 , 等 . 考虑虚拟电厂灵活调节特性的现货市场出清模型及灵活性溢价评估方法 [J]. 电网技术 , 2023 , 47 1 : 194 ‒ 207 .
Gao H C , Chen Q X , Jin T , al e t . Clearing model and flexible premium evaluation method of spot market considering flexible regulatable characteristics of virtual power plant [J]. Power System Technology , 2023 , 47 1 : 194 ‒ 207 .
[63] Cai T T, Dong M Y, Chen K, al et. Methods of participating power spot market bidding and settlement for renewable energy systems [J]. Energy Reports, 2022 (8): 7764‒7772.