2006, Volume 8, Issue 6
Strategic Study of CAE >> 2006, Volume 8, Issue 6
The Application of Risk Matrix to Acquisition Risk Evaluation for Weapon and Equipment
1. China Academy Science Institute of Policy and Management, Beijing 100080, China
2. Business School, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, China
3. The Equipment Institute of the Second Artillery, Beijing 100085, China
Next Previous
Abstract
Risk evaluation is the basis of acquisition management for weapon and equipment. Based on the totally analyzing and summarizing risk matrix widely used abroad, the paper firsdy discusses the application of risk matrix in acquisition risk evaluation for weapon and equipment in China. Then, the paper, beginning with the two rules of risk impact and risk probability, demonstrates risk evaluation of a type of weapon and equipment as a case study, thus lays a basis for the scientific and rational risk management decision making.
Figures
图1
图10
图2
图3
图4
图5
图6
图7
图8
图9
References
[ 1 ] 邹国晨, 赵澄谋, 邱衡.武器装备采办管理[M].北京:国防工业出版社, 2003.6~10
[ 2 ] Garvey P R, Lansdowne Z F.Risk matrix:an approachfor identifying, assessing, and ranking program risks[J]Air Force Journal of Logistics, 1998, 22 (1) :16~23
[ 3 ] Willhite M A.Establishing a Program Risk Baseline, anAnnotated Briefing[R].Bedford:The MITRECorporation, 1998.1~10
[ 4 ] Engert P A, .Lansdowne Z F.Risk Matrix User s Guide[R].Bedford:The MITRE Corporation, 1999.18~39
[ 5 ] Cook W D, Seiford L M.On the borda-kendall consensusmethod for priority ranking problems[J].ManagementScience, 1982, 28:621~637
[ 6 ] Lansdowne Z F.Ordinal ranking methods for multicriteriondecision making[J].Naval Research Logistics, 1996, 43:613~627
[ 7 ] Lansdowne Z F, Woodward B S.Applying the bordaranking method[J].Air Force Journal of Logistics, 1996, 20 (2) :27~29
[ 8 ] Fishburn P C, Gehrlein W V.Borda s rule, positionalvoting, and condorcet s simple majority principle[J].Public Choice, 1976, 28:79~88 link1
[ 9 ] Van Newenhizen J.The borda method is most likely torespect the condorcet principle[J].Economic Theory, 1992, 2:69~83 link1
[10] Saari D G.Geometry of Voting[M].New York:Springer-Verlag Press, 1994.23~35
[11] Defense Acquisition University Defense SystemsManagement College.Risk Management Guide for DoDAcquisition (Fourth Edition) [M].Virginia:DefenseSystems Management College Press, 1998.29~33
[12] 管清波, 罗小明, 杜红梅.模糊综合评判法在装备采办风险评价中的运用研究[J].装备指挥技术学院学报, 2002, 13 (4) :18~20 link1
[13] Defense Acquisition University (DAU) .Risk ManagementGuide for DOD Acquisition[M].Virginia:DefenseSystems Management College Press, 2001.5~9
[14] Bailey R O.Analysis of Current Department of DefenseRisk Management Practices in Weapon System Acquisition:A Case Study of the Advanced Amphibious Assualt VehiclePDRR and SDD Risk Management Practices[D].California:Naval Postgraduate School, 2003
[15] RossJ P.A Risk Management Model for the FederalAcquisition Process[D].California:Naval PostgraduateSchool, 1999
[16] Ansell J W.Risk:Analysis, Assessment, and Management[M].New York:New York Press, 1992.34~63
京公网安备 11010502051620号
