Journal Home Online First Current Issue Archive For Authors Journal Information 中文版

Engineering >> 2020, Volume 6, Issue 7 doi: 10.1016/j.eng.2020.06.002

State-of-the-Art Analysis and Perspectives for Peer-to-Peer Energy Trading

School of Engineering, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 3AA, United Kingdom

Received: 2019-03-26 Revised: 2019-08-22 Accepted: 2019-11-22 Available online: 2020-06-10

Next Previous

Abstract

As a promising solution to address the “energy trilemma” confronting human society, peer-to-peer (P2P) energy trading has emerged and rapidly developed in recent years. When carrying out P2P energy trading, customers with distributed energy resources (DERs) are able to directly trade and share energy with each other. This paper summarizes and analyzes the global development of P2P energy trading based on a comprehensive review of related academic papers, research projects, and industrial practice. Key aspects in P2P energy trading are identified and discussed, including market design, trading platforms, physical infrastructure and information and communication technology (ICT) infrastructure, social science perspectives, and policy. For each key aspect, existing research and practice are critically reviewed and insights for future development are presented. Comprehensive concluding remarks are provided at the end, summarizing the major findings and perspectives of this paper. P2P energy trading is a growing field with great potential and opportunities for both academia and industry across the world.

Figures

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

Fig. 3

Fig. 4

Fig. 5

Fig. 6

Fig. 7

Fig. 8

Fig. 9

References

[ 1 ] World Energy Council. World energy trilemma [Internet]. London: World Energy Council; 2017 [cited 2019 Jul 3]. Available from: https:// www.worldenergy.org/transition-toolkit/world-energy-trilemma-index. link1

[ 2 ] International Energy Agency. WEO-2014 special report: world energy investment outlook [Internet]. Paris: International Energy Agency; 2014 Jun 3 [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://webstore.iea.org/weo-2014- special-report-world-energy-investment-outlook. link1

[ 3 ] Global Energy Interconnection Development and Cooperation Organization. Overview [Internet]. Beijing: Global Energy Interconnection Development and Cooperation Organization; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://en. geidco.org/. link1

[ 4 ] Ofgem. Ofgem’s future insights paper 3 local energy in a transforming energy system [Internet]. London: Ofgem; 2017 Jan 30 [cited 2019 Mar 25]. Available from: https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/publications-and-updates/ofgem-futureinsights-series-local-energy-transforming-energy-system. link1

[ 5 ] Economist Intelligence Unit. The global energy conversation part II: solutions to 2050 [Internet]. London: The Economist group; [cited 2019 Jul 3]. Available from: http://www.economist.com/sites/default/files/gec2_2011_summary_ paper_a4_v20_web.pdf. link1

[ 6 ] Energy UK. Pathways for the GB electricity sector to 2030 chapter 2: whole system approach [Internet]. London: Energy UK; [cited 2019 Jul 3]. Available from: https:// www.energy-uk.org.uk/publication.html?task=file.download&id=5719. link1

[ 7 ] Hong B, Zhang W, Zhou Y, Chen J, Xiang Y, Mu Y. Energy-Internet-oriented microgrid energy management system architecture and its application in China. Appl Energy 2018;228:2153–64. link1

[ 8 ] Yazdanie M, Densing M, Wokaun A. The nationwide characterization and modeling of local energy systems: quantifying the role of decentralized generation and energy resources in future communities. Energy Policy 2018;118:516–33. link1

[ 9 ] US Energy Information Administration. Electricity explained: how electricity is delivered to consumers [Internet]. Washington, DC: US Energy Information Administration; [cited 2019 Jul 14]. Available from: https://www.eia.gov/ energyexplained/index.php?page=electricity_delivery. link1

[10] Cui X. The UK electricity markets: its evolution, wholesale prices and challenge of wind energy [dissertation]. Stirling: University of Stirling; 2010. link1

[11] Rodríguez-Molina J, Martínez-Núñez M, Martínez J, Pérez-Aguiar W. Business models in the smart grid: challenges, opportunities and proposals for prosumer profitability. Energies 2014;7(9):6142–71. link1

[12] Wang C, Wang D, Zhou Y. Framework analysis and technical challenges to smart distribution system. Autom Elctr Power Syst 2015;39(9):2–9. Chinese.

[13] Zhong W, Yu R, Xie S, Zhang Y, Tsang DHK. Software defined networking for flexible and green energy Internet. IEEE Commun Mag 2016;54(12):68–75. link1

[14] UK Research and Innovation. Peer-to-peer energy trading and sharing 3M (multi-times, multi-scales, multi-qualities) [Internet]. Swindon: UK Research and Innovation; [cited 2019 Jul 15]. Available from: https://gtr.ukri.org/ projects?ref=EP%2FN03466X%2F1.

[15] Verv Energy. The sharing economy: let’s talk about the ‘peer-to-peer’ in energy trading [Internet]. [cited 2019 Jul 15]. Available from: https://medium.com/@ VervEnergy/the-sharing-economy-lets-talk-about-the-peer-to-peer-in-energytrading-e4e679307f89. link1

[16] Zhou Y, Wu J, Long C, Cheng M, Zhang C. Performance evaluation of peer-topeer energy sharing models. Energy Procedia 2017;143:817–22. link1

[17] Zhou Y, Wu J, Long C. Evaluation of peer-to-peer energy sharing mechanisms based on a multiagent simulation framework. Appl Energy 2018;222: 993–1022. link1

[18] Electricity’s future may be peer-to-peer. Electr J 2016;29(6):3–4.

[19] Papadaskalopoulos D, Strbac G. Decentralized participation of flexible demand in electricity markets–part I: market mechanism. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2013;28(4):3658–66.

[20] Zhang C, Wu J, Zhou Y, Cheng M, Long C. Peer-to-peer energy trading in a microgrid. Appl Energy 2018;220:1–12. link1

[21] Morstyn T, Farrell N, Darby SJ, McCulloch MD. Using peer-to-peer energytrading platforms to incentivize prosumers to form federated power plants. Nat Energy 2018;3(2):94–101. link1

[22] European Commission. P2P-SmarTest [Internet]. Brussels: European Commission; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/inea/ en/horizon-2020/projects/h2020-energy/grids/p2p-smartest. link1

[23] Li F, Strbac G, Jeon J, McCulloch M, Adebisi B, Li R. Peer-to-peer energy trading and sharing 3M (multi-times, multi-scales, multi-qualities) [Internet]. Swindon: EPSRC; 2016 Sep 1 [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://gow.epsrc.ukri.org/NGBOViewGrant.aspx?GrantRef=EP/N03466X/1. link1

[24] The Energy Collective. The energy collective project—towards direct sharing and trading of electric energy! [Internet]. Copenhagen: The Energy Collective; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://the-energy-collective-project.com/. link1

[25] Verma P, O’Regan B, Hayes B, Thakur S, Breslin JG. EnerPort: Irish Blockchain project for peer-to-peer energy trading. Energy Inf 2018;1(14):1–9. link1

[26] European Commission. Neighbourhood Oriented Brokerage ELectricity and monitoring system [Internet]. Brussels: European Commission; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://cordis.europa.eu/project/rcn/94044/factsheet/en. link1

[27] The University of Queensland. Peer-to-peer energy trading schemes for sustainable cities (2017–2020) [Internet]. St Lucia: The University of Queensland; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: http://researchers.uq.edu. au/research-project/31099. link1

[28] Software-Cluster. Peer energy cloud—efficient energy management from the cloud [Internet]. Weilerbach: Software-Cluster; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: http://oldweb.software-cluster.com/en/research/projects/partnerprojects/peer-energy-cloud. link1

[29] UK Research and Innovation. Street2Grid—an electricity blockchain platform for P2P energy trading [Internet]. Swindon: UK Research and Innovation; [cited 2019 Mar 20]. Available from: https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=EP% 2FS001778%2F1.

[30] Singh A, Strating AT, Romero Herrera NA, van Dijk HW, Keyson DV. Towards an ethnography of electrification in rural India: social relations and values in household energy exchanges. Energy Res Soc Sci 2017;30:103–15. link1

[31] Da Silva PG, Ilic´ D, Karnouskos S. The impact of smart grid prosumer grouping on forecasting accuracy and its benefits for local electricity market trading. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2014;5(1):402–10. link1

[32] Velik R, Nicolay P. Grid-price-dependent energy management in microgrids using a modified simulated annealing triple-optimizer. Appl Energy 2014;130:384–95. link1

[33] Luo Y, Itaya S, Nakamura S, Davis P. Autonomous cooperative energy trading between prosumers for microgrid systems. In: Proceedings of the 39th Annual IEEE Conference on Local Computer Networks Workshops; 2014 Sep 8–11; Edmonton, AB, Canada; 2014. p. 1–4.

[34] Mihaylov M, Jurado S, Avellana N, van Moffaert K, de Abril IM, Nowé A. NRGcoin: virtual currency for trading of renewable energy in smart grids. In: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on the European Energy Market; 2014 May 28–30; Krakow, Poland; 2014. p. 1–6.

[35] Cui T, Wang Y, Nazarian S, Pedram M. An electricity trade model for multiple power distribution networks in smart energy systems. In: Proceedings of the 2014 IEEE PES General Meeting; 2014 Jul 27–31; National Harbor, MD, USA; 2014. p. 1–5.

[36] Mohn T, Piasecki R. A smarter grid enables communal microgrids. In: Proceedings of the 2011 IEEE Green Technologies Conference; 2011 Apr 14– 15; Baton Rouge, LA, USA; 2011. p. 1–6.

[37] Ilic D, Da Silva PG, Karnouskos S, Griesemer M. An energy market for trading electricity in smart grid neighbourhoods. In: Proceedings of the 2012 6th IEEE International Conference on Digital Ecosystems and Technologies; 2012 Jun 18–20; Campione d’Italia, Italy; 2012. p. 1–6.

[38] Long C, Wu J, Zhou Y, Jenkins N. Peer-to-peer energy sharing through a twostage aggregated battery control in a community Microgrid. Appl Energy 2018;226:261–76.

[39] Nguyen S, Peng W, Sokolowski P, Alahakoon D, Yu X. Optimizing rooftop photovoltaic distributed generation with battery storage for peer-to-peer energy trading. Appl Energy 2018;228:2567–80.

[40] Lüth A, Zepter JM, del Granado PC, Egging R. Local electricity market designs for peer-to-peer trading: the role of battery flexibility. Appl Energy 2018;229:1233–43.

[41] Hou W, Guo L, Ning Z. Local electricity storage for blockchain-based energy trading in industrial Internet of things. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2019;15(6):3610–9.

[42] Zepter JM, Lüth A, del Granado PC, Egging R. Prosumer integration in wholesale electricity markets: synergies of peer-to-peer trade and residential storage. Energy Build 2019;184:163–76.

[43] Alam MR, St-Hilaire M, Kunz T. Peer-to-peer energy trading among smart homes. Appl Energy 2019;238:1434–43.

[44] Ecker F, Spada H, Hahnel UJJ. Independence without control: autarky outperforms autonomy benefits in the adoption of private energy storage systems. Energy Policy 2018;122:214–28.

[45] Morstyn T, Teytelboym A, McCulloch MD. Bilateral contract networks for peerto-peer energy trading. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2019;10(2):2026–35. link1

[46] Sorin E, Bobo L, Pinson P. Consensus-based approach to peer-to-peer electricity markets with product differentiation. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2019;34(2):994–1004. link1

[47] Devine MT, Cuffe P. Blockchain electricity trading under demurrage. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2019;10(2):2323–5. link1

[48] Luo F, Dong ZY, Liang G, Murata J, Xu Z. A distributed electricity trading system in active distribution networks based on multiagent coalition and blockchain. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2019;34(5):4097–108. link1

[49] Guerrero J, Chapman A, Verbic G. A study of energy trading in a low-voltage network: centralised and distributed approaches. In: Proceedings of the 2017 Australasian Universities Power Engineering Conference; 2017 Nov 19–22; Melbourne, VIC, Australia; 2017. p. 1–6.

[50] Guerrero J, Chapman AC, Verbicˇ G. Decentralized P2P energy trading under network constraints in a low-voltage network. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2019;10 (5):5163–73. link1

[51] Kang J, Yu R, Huang X, Maharjan S, Zhang Y, Hossain E. Enabling localized peerto-peer electricity trading among plug-in hybrid electric vehicles using consortium blockchains. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2017;13(6):3154–64. link1

[52] Li Z, Kang J, Yu R, Ye D, Deng Q, Zhang Y. Consortium blockchain for secure energy trading in industrial Internet of things. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2018;14 (8):3690–700. link1

[53] Long C, Wu J, Zhang C, Thomas L, Cheng M, Jenkins N. Peer-to-peer energy trading in a community microgrid. In: Proceedings of the 2017 IEEE PES General Meeting; 2017 Jul 16–20; Chicago, IL, USA; 2017. p. 1–5.

[54] Alvaro-Hermana R, Fraile-Ardanuy J, Zufiria PJ, Knapen L, Janssens D. Peer-topeer energy trading with electric vehicles. IEEE Intell Transp Syst Mag 2016;8 (3):33–44. link1

[55] Morstyn T, McCulloch MD. Multi-class energy management for peer-to-peer energy trading driven by prosumer preferences. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2019;34(5):4005–14. link1

[56] Paudel A, Chaudhari K, Long C, Gooi HB. Peer-to-peer energy trading in a prosumer-based community microgrid: a game-theoretic model. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 2018. link1

[57] Baroche T, Pinson P, Latimier RLG, Ahmed HB. Exogenous cost allocation in peer-to-peer electricity markets. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2019;34(4):2553–64. link1

[58] Chen T, Su W. Indirect customer-to-customer energy trading with reinforcement learning. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2019;10(4):4338–48. link1

[59] Liu N, Yu X, Wang C, Li C, Ma L, Lei J. Energy-sharing model with price-based demand response for microgrids of peer-to-peer prosumers. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2017;32(5):3569–83. link1

[60] Paterakis NG, Erdinç O, Catalão JPS. An overview of demand response: keyelements and international experience. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2017;69:871–91. link1

[61] Zhang S, Qin X. Lessons learned from China’s residential tiered electricity pricing reform [Internet]. Winnipeg: The International Institute for Sustainable Development; 2015 [cited 2019 Jul 10]. Available from: https://www.iisd.org/ gsi/sites/default/files/ffsr_china_lessons_learned_may_2015.pdf. link1

[62] BC Hydro. Evaluation of the residential inclining block rate [Internet]. [cited 2019 Jul 10]. Available from: https://www.bchydro.com/content/ dam/BCHydro/customer-portal/documents/corporate/regulatory-planningdocuments/revenue-requirements/10-RIB-Evaluation-report.pdf. link1

[63] Smart Energy International. Introduction of inclining block tariffs benefits low income domestic customers in South Africa [Internet]. Rondebosch: Smart Energy International; 2012 Jun 15 [cited 2019 Jul 10]. Available from: https:// www.smart-energy.com/regional-news/africa-middle-east/introduction-ofinclining-block-tariffs-benefits-low-income-domestic-customers-in-southafrica/. link1

[64] Tushar W, Saha TK, Yuen C, Liddell P, Bean R, Poor HV. Peer-to-peer energy trading with sustainable user participation: a game theoretic approach. IEEE Access 2018;6:62932–43. link1

[65] Wu FF, Varaiya PP, Hui RSY. Smart grids with intelligent periphery: an architecture for the energy Internet. Engineering 2015;1(4):436–46. link1

[66] Jones R, Haley B, Kwok G, Hargreaves J, Williams J. Electrification and the future of electricity markets: transitioning to a low-carbon energy system. IEEE Power Energy Mag 2018;16(4):79–89. link1

[67] Litvinov E, Zhao F, Zheng T. Electricity markets in the United States: power industry restructuring processes for the present and future. IEEE Power Energy Mag 2019;17(1):32–42. link1

[68] Sousa T, Soares T, Pinson P, Moret F, Baroche T, Sorin E. Peer-to-peer and community-based markets: a comprehensive review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2019;104:367–78. link1

[69] Tushar W, Yuen C, Mohsenian-Rad H, Saha T, Poor HV, Wood KL. Transforming energy networks via peer-to-peer energy trading: the potential of game theoretic approaches. IEEE Signal Process Mag 2018;35(4):90–111. link1

[70] Ahl A, Yarime M, Tanaka K, Sagawa D. Review of blockchain-based distributed energy: implications for institutional development. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2019;107:200–11. link1

[71] Brilliantova V, Thurner TW. Blockchain and the future of energy. Technol Soc 2019;57:38–45. link1

[72] Walport M. Distributed ledger technology: beyond block chain [Internet]. London: GOV.UK; 2016 Jan 19 [cited 2019 Jul 10]. Available: https://www.gov. uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/492972/gs-16- 1-distributed-ledger-technology.pdf. link1

[73] Mengelkamp E, Gärttner J, Rock K, Kessler S, Orsini L, Weinhardt C. Designing microgrid energy markets: a case study: the Brooklyn microgrid. Appl Energy 2018;210:870–80. link1

[74] Andoni M, Robu V, Flynn D, Abram S, Geach D, Jenkins D, et al. Blockchain technology in the energy sector: a systematic review of challenges and opportunities. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2019;100:143–74. link1

[75] Aitzhan NZ, Svetinovic D. Security and privacy in decentralized energy trading through multi-signatures, blockchain and anonymous messaging streams. IEEE Trans Depend Secure Comput 2018;15(5):840–52. link1

[76] Kahn AE. The economics of regulation: institutional issues. New York: Wiley; 1971. link1

[77] Nepal R, Foster J. Electricity networks privatization in Australia: an overview of the debate. Econ Anal Policy 2015;48:12–24. link1

[78] Werth A, Kitamura N, Tanaka K. Conceptual study for open energy systems: distributed energy network using interconnected DC nanogrids. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2015;6(4):1621–30. link1

[79] Kumar M, Srivastava SC, Singh SN, Ramamoorty M. Development of a control strategy for interconnection of islanded direct current microgrids. IET Renew Power Gener 2015;9(3):284–96. link1

[80] Hossain MJ, Mahmud MA, Milano F, Bacha S, Hably A. Design of robust distributed control for interconnected microgrids. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2016;7(6):2724–35. link1

[81] Konar S, Ghosh A. Interconnection of islanded DC microgrids. In: Proceedings of 2015 IEEE PES Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference; 2015 Nov 15–18; Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 2015. p. 1–5.

[82] Nguyen PH, Kling WL, Ribeiro PF. Smart power router: a flexible agent-based converter interface in active distribution networks. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2011;2(3):487–95. link1

[83] Sánchez-Squella A, Ortega R, Griño R, Malo S. Dynamic energy router. IEEE Control Syst Mag 2010;30(6):72–80. link1

[84] Ma J, Song L, Li Y. Optimal power dispatching for local area packetized power network. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2018;9(5):4765–76. link1

[85] Wang R, Wu J, Qian Z, Lin Z, He X. A graph theory based energy routing algorithm in energy local area network. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2017;13 (6):3275–85. link1

[86] Abdella J, Shuaib K. Peer to peer distributed energy trading in smart grids: a survey. Energies 2018;11(6):1560. link1

[87] Nikolaidis AI, Charalambous CA, Mancarella P. A graph-based loss allocation framework for transactive energy markets in unbalanced radial distribution networks. IEEE Trans Power Syst 2019;34(5):4109–18. link1

[88] Jogunola O, Ikpehai A, Anoh K, Adebisi B, Hammoudeh M, Gacanin H, et al. Comparative analysis of P2P architectures for energy trading and sharing. Energies 2018;11(1):62. link1

[89] Zhang C. Peer-to-peer energy trading in electrical distribution networks [dissertation]. Cardiff: Cardiff University; 2017. link1

[90] Singh A, Strating AT, Herrera NAR, Mahato D, Keyson DV, van Dijk HW. Exploring peer-to-peer returns in off-grid renewable energy systems in rural India: an anthropological perspective on local energy sharing and trading. Energy Res Soc Sci 2018;46:194–213. link1

[91] Giotitsas C, Pazaitis A, Kostakis V. A peer-to-peer approach to energy production. Technol Soc 2015;42:28–38. link1

[92] Diestelmeier L. Changing power: shifting the role of electricity consumers with blockchain technology—policy implications for EU electricity law. Energy Policy 2019;128:189–96.

Related Research