Journal Home Online First Current Issue Archive For Authors Journal Information 中文版

Engineering >> 2023, Volume 21, Issue 2 doi: 10.1016/j.eng.2022.08.017

Global Significance of Substrates for Nitrate Removal in Denitrifying Bioreactors Revealed by Meta-Analysis

a Biosystems Engineering and Soil Science, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA

b University of Florida, Everglades Research and Education Center, Belle Glade, FL 33430, USA

c Center for Environmental Biotechnology, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA

d Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA

Received: 2021-05-31 Revised: 2021-10-13 Accepted: 2022-08-01 Available online: 2022-11-21

Next Previous

Abstract

Denitrifying bioreactors (DNBRs) are widely used to reduce excess nitrate from agricultural drainage. Their performance depends on the physical and chemical properties of the substrate. Common substrate types have been partly reviewed in previous studies. However, few studies have attempted to determine a generalized pattern for the role of substrate type in nitrate removal. This study summarizes 41 types of
substrates using a dataset collected from 63 peer-reviewed articles, which include 219 independent DNBR units. The substrates are classified into four groups: ① natural carbon (NC), such as woodchips; ② non-natural carbon (NNC), such as biodegradable polymers (e.g., polycaprolactone (PCL) and waste products (e.g., cardboard); ③ inorganic materials (IMs), such as non-carbon materials (e.g., iron oxide); and④multiple materials (MMs), such as a mixture of the above materials. These materials are compared and evaluated through a meta-analysis of nitrate removal rate (NRR; N removal (g∙m3∙d–1)) and nitrate removal efficiency (NRE). This study reviews substrate performance (NRR and NRE), potential mechanisms, pollution swapping, and cost analysis. Our analysis indicates that woodchips and corncobs are the most cost-effective substrates among NCs. In a comparison of all the studied substrates, MM substrates are recommended as the optimal substrates, especially woodchip-based and corncob-based substrates, which have great potential for improvement. This analysis can assist in optimizing the design of DNBRs to meet the environmental, economic, and practical requirements of users.

SupplementaryMaterials

Figures

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

Fig. 3

Fig. 4

Fig. 5

Fig. 6

Fig. 7

Fig. 8

Fig. 9

References

[ 1 ] Ju XT, Xing GX, Chen XP, Zhang SL, Zhang LJ, Liu XJ, et al. Reducing environmental risk by improving N management in intensive Chinese agricultural systems. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2009;106(9):3041–6.

[ 2 ] Tian H, Liang X, Gong Y, Qi L, Liu Q, Kang Z, et al. Health risk assessment of nitrate pollution in shallow groundwater: a case study in China. Pol J Environ Stud 2020;29(1):827–39.

[ 3 ] Miao S, Jin C, Liu R, Bai Y, Liu H, Hu C, et al. Microbial community structures and functions of hypersaline heterotrophic denitrifying process: lab-scale and pilot-scale studies. Bioresour Technol 2020;310:123244.

[ 4 ] Coleman BSL, Easton ZM, Bock EM. Biochar fails to enhance nutrient removal in woodchip bioreactor columns following saturation. J Environ Manage 2019;232:490–8.

[ 5 ] Robertson WD, Vogan JL, Lombardo PS. Nitrate removal rates in a 15-year-old permeable reactive barrier treating septic system nitrate. Ground WaterMonit Remediat 2008;28(3):65–72.

[ 6 ] Long LM, Schipper LA, Bruesewitz DA. Long-term nitrate removal in a denitrification wall. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2011;140(3–4):514–20.

[ 7 ] Christianson L, Tyndall J, Helmers M. Financial comparison of seven nitrate reduction strategies for Midwestern agricultural drainage. Water Resour Econ 2013;2–3:30–56.

[ 8 ] Addy K, Gold AJ, Christianson LE, David MB, Schipper LA, Ratigan NA. Denitrifying bioreactors for nitrate removal: a meta-analysis. J Environ Qual 2016;45(3):873–81.

[ 9 ] Schipper LA, Robertson WD, Gold AJ, Jaynes DB, Cameron SC. Denitrifying bioreactors—an approach for reducing nitrate loads to receiving waters. Ecol Eng 2010;36(11):1532–43.

[10] Schipper LA, Vojvodic´ -Vukovic´ M. Nitrate removal from groundwater and denitrification rates in a porous treatment wall amended with sawdust. Ecol Eng 2000;14(3):269–78.

[11] Schipper L, Vojvodic-Vukovic M. Nitrate removal from groundwater using a denitrification wall amended with sawdust: field trial. J Environ Qual 1998;27(3):664–8.

[12] Blowes DW, Robertson WD, Ptacek CJ, Merkley C. Removal of agricultural nitrate from tile-drainage effluent water using in-line bioreactors. J Contam Hydrol 1994;15(3):207–21.

[13] Healy MG, Rodgers M, Mulqueen J. Denitrification of a nitrate-rich synthetic wastewater using various wood-based media materials. J Environ Sci Health Part A Tox Hazard Subst Environ Eng 2006;41(5):779–88.

[14] Van Driel P, Robertson W, Merkley L. Denitrification of agricultural drainage using wood-based reactors. Trans ASABE 2006;49(2):565–73.

[15] Sharrer KL, Christianson LE, Lepine C, Summerfelt ST. Modeling and mitigation of denitrification ‘woodchip’ bioreactor phosphorus releases during treatment of aquaculture wastewater. Ecol Eng 2016;93:135–43.

[16] Feyereisen GW, Moorman TB, Christianson LE, Venterea RT, Coulter JA, Tschirner UW. Performance of agricultural residue media in laboratory denitrifying bioreactors at low temperatures. J Environ Qual 2016;45 (3):779–87.

[17] Soares MIM, Abeliovich A. Wheat straw as substrate for water denitrification. Water Res 1998;32(12):3790–4.

[18] Aslan S, Türkman A. Combined biological removal of nitrate and pesticides using wheat straw as substrates. Process Biochem 2005;40(2):935–43.

[19] Liu F, Wang Y, Xiao R, Wu J, Li Y, Zhang S, et al. Influence of substrates on nutrient removal performance of organic channel barriers in drainage ditches. J Hydrol 2015;527:380–6.

[20] Della Rocca C, Belgiorno V, Meric S. Cotton-supported heterotrophic denitrification of nitrate-rich drinking water with a sand filtration posttreatment. Water SA 2005;31(2):229–36.

[21] Della Rocca C, Belgiorno V, Meriç S. An heterotrophic/autotrophic denitrification (HAD) approach for nitrate removal from drinking water. Process Biochem 2006;41(5):1022–8.

[22] Greenan CM, Moorman TB, Kaspar TC, Parkin TB, Jaynes DB. Comparing carbon substrates for denitrification of subsurface drainage water. J Environ Qual 2006;35(3):824–9.

[23] Gibert O, Pomierny S, Rowe I, Kalin RM. Selection of organic substrates as potential reactive materials for use in a denitrification permeable reactive barrier (PRB). Bioresour Technol 2008;99(16):7587–96.

[24] Healy MG, Barrett M, Lanigan GJ, João Serrenho A, Ibrahim TG, Thornton SF, et al. Optimizing nitrate removal and evaluating pollution swapping trade-offs from laboratory denitrification bioreactors. Ecol Eng 2015;74: 290–301.

[25] Healy MG, Ibrahim TG, Lanigan GJ, Serrenho AJ, Fenton O. Nitrate removal rate, efficiency and pollution swapping potential of different organic carbon media in laboratory denitrification bioreactors. Ecol Eng 2012;40:198–209.

[26] Cameron SG, Schipper LA. Nitrate removal and hydraulic performance of organic carbon for use in denitrification beds. Ecol Eng 2010;36(11):1588–95.

[27] Cameron SG, Schipper LA. Hydraulic properties, hydraulic efficiency and nitrate removal of organic carbon media for use in denitrification beds. Ecol Eng 2012;41:1–7.

[28] Hua G, Salo MW, Schmit CG, Hay CH. Nitrate and phosphate removal from agricultural subsurface drainage using laboratory woodchip bioreactors and recycled steel byproduct filters. Water Res 2016;102:180–9.

[29] Bock EM, Coleman B, Easton ZM. Effect of biochar on nitrate removal in a pilot-scale denitrifying bioreactor. J Environ Qual 2016;45(3):762–71.

[30] Bock E, Smith N, Rogers M, Coleman B, Reiter M, Benham B, et al. Enhanced nitrate and phosphate removal in a denitrifying bioreactor with biochar. J Environ Qual 2015;44(2):605–13.

[31] Bruun J, Hoffmann CC, Kjaergaard C. Nitrogen removal in permeable woodchip filters affected by hydraulic loading rate and woodchip ratio. J Environ Qual 2016;45(5):1688–95.

[32] Roser MB, Feyereisen GW, Spokas KA, Mulla DJ, Strock JS, Gutknecht J. Carbon dosing increases nitrate removal rates in denitrifying bioreactors at lowtemperature high-flow conditions. J Environ Qual 2018;47(4):856–64.

[33] Li S, Cooke RA, Huang X, Christianson L, Bhattarai R. Evaluation of fly ash pellets for phosphorus removal in a laboratory scale denitrifying bioreactor. J Environ Manage 2018;207:269–75.

[34] Kiani S, Kujala K, Pulkkinen JT, Aalto SL, Suurnäkki S, Kiuru T, et al. Enhanced nitrogen removal of low carbon wastewater in denitrification bioreactors by utilizing industrial waste toward circular economy. J Clean Prod 2020;254:119973.

[35] Berger AW, Valenca R, Miao Y, Ravi S, Mahendra S, Mohanty SK. Biochar increases nitrate removal capacity of woodchip biofilters during highintensity rainfall. Water Res 2019;165:115008.

[36] Bock EM, Coleman BSL, Easton ZM. Performance of an under-loaded denitrifying bioreactor with biochar amendment. J Environ Manage 2018;217:447–55.

[37] Boley A, Müller WR, Haider G. Biodegradable polymers as solid substrate and biofilm carrier for denitrification in recirculated aquaculture systems. Aquacult Eng 2000;22(1–2):75–85.

[38] Honda Y, Osawa Z. Microbial denitrification of wastewater using biodegradable polycaprolactone. Polym Degrad Stabil 2002;76(2):321–7.

[39] Walters E, Hille A, He M, Ochmann C, Horn H. Simultaneous nitrification/denitrification in a biofilm airlift suspension (BAS) reactor with biodegradable carrier material. Water Res 2009;43(18):4461–8.

[40] Zhou H, Zhao X, Wang J. Nitrate removal from groundwater using biodegradable polymers as carbon source and biofilm support. Int J Environ Pollut 2009;38(3):339–48.

[41] Li R, Feng CP, Xi BD, Chen N, Jiang Y, Zhao Y, et al. Nitrate removal efficiency of a mixotrophic denitrification wall for nitrate-polluted groundwater in situ remediation. Ecol Eng 2017;106(Pt A):523–31.

[42] Shen Z, Hu J, Wang J, Zhou Y. Comparison of polycaprolactone and starch/ polycaprolactone blends as carbon source for biological denitrification. Int J Environ Sci Technol 2015;12(4):1235–42.

[43] Fenton O, Healy MG, Brennan F, Jahangir MMR, Lanigan GJ, Richards KG, et al. Permeable reactive interceptors: blocking diffuse nutrient and greenhouse gases losses in key areas of the farming landscape. J Agric Sci 2014;152 (S1):71–81.

[44] Warneke S, Schipper LA, Matiasek MG, Scow KM, Cameron S, Bruesewitz DA, et al. Nitrate removal, communities of denitrifiers and adverse effects in different carbon substrates for use in denitrification beds. Water Res 2011;45 (17):5463–75.

[45] Volokita M, Belkin S, Abeliovich A, Soares MIM. Biological denitrification of drinking water using newspaper. Water Res 1996;30(4):965–71.

[46] Xu B, Shi L, Zhong H, Wang K. The performance of pyrite-based autotrophic denitrification column for permeable reactive barrier under natural environment. Bioresour Technol 2019;290(10):121763.

[47] Xing W, Li J, Li D, Hu J, Deng S, Cui Y, et al. Stable-isotope probing reveals the activity and function of autotrophic and heterotrophic denitrifiers in nitrate removal from organic-limited wastewater. Environ Sci Technol 2018;52 (14):7867–75.

[48] Aalto SL, Suurnäkki S, von Ahnen M, Siljanen HMP, Pedersen PB, Tiirola M. Nitrate removal microbiology in woodchip bioreactors: a case-study with full-scale bioreactors treating aquaculture effluents. Sci Total Environ 2020;723:138093.

[49] Rambags F, Tanner CC, Schipper LA. Denitrification and anammox remove nitrogen in denitrifying bioreactors. Ecol Eng 2019;138:38–45.

[50] Liu T, Chen D, Luo X, Li X, Li F. Microbially mediated nitrate-reducing Fe(II) oxidation: quantification of chemodenitrification and biological reactions. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 2019;256:97–115.

[51] Christianson L, Bhandari A, Helmers M, Kult K, Sutphin T, Wolf R. Performance evaluation of four field-scale agricultural drainage denitrification bioreactors in Iowa. Trans ASABE 2012;55(6):2163–74.

[52] Christianson LE, Cooke RA, Hay CH, Helmers MJ, Feyereisen GW, Ranaivoson AZ, et al. Effectiveness of denitrifying bioreactors on water pollutant reduction from agricultural areas. Trans ASABE 2021;64(2):641–58.

[53] Grießmeier V, Leberecht K, Gescher J. NO3 - removal efficiency in field denitrification beds: key controlling factors and main implications. Environ Microbiol Rep 2019;11(3):316–29.

[54] Yao ZB, Wang CL, Song N, Jiang H. Development of a hybrid biofilm reactor for nitrate removal from surface water with macrophyte residues as carbon substrate. Ecol Eng 2019;128:1–8.

[55] Peng W, Pivato A, Garbo F, Wang T. Stabilization of solid digestate and nitrogen removal from mature leachate in landfill simulation bioreactors packed with aged refuse. J Environ Manage 2019;232:957–63.

[56] Israel H, Richter RR. A guide to understanding meta-analysis. J Orthop Sport Phys 2011;41(7):496–504.

[57] Wallace BC, Lajeunesse MJ, Dietz G, Dahabreh IJ, Trikalinos TA, Schmid CH, et al. OpenMEE: intuitive, open-source software for meta-analysis in ecology and evolutionary biology. MethodsEcol Evol 2017;8(8):941–7.

[58] Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, Inc.; 2000.

[59] Zhang W, Ruan X, Bai Y, Yin L. The characteristics and performance of sustainable-releasing compound carbon source material applied on groundwater nitrate in-situ remediation. Chemosphere 2018;205:635–42.

[60] Cornwell WK, Cornelissen JHC, Allison SD, Bauhus J, Eggleton P, Preston CM, et al. Plant traits and wood fates across the globe: rotted, burned, or consumed? Glob Change Biol 2009;15(10):2431–49.

[61] Pluer WT, Geohring LD, Steenhuis TS, Todd WM. Controls influencing the treatment of excess agricultural nitrate with denitrifying bioreactors. J Environ Qual 2016;45(3):772–8.

[62] Kouanda A, Hua G. Determination of nitrate removal kinetics model parameters in woodchip bioreactors. Water Res 2021;195:116974.

[63] Rivas A, Barkle G, Stenger R, Moorhead B, Clague J. Nitrate removal and secondary effects of a woodchip bioreactor for the treatment of subsurface drainage with dynamic flows under pastoral agriculture. Ecol Eng 2020;148:105786.

[64] Chu L, Wang J. Nitrogen removal using biodegradable polymers as carbon source and biofilm carriers in a moving bed biofilm reactor. Chem Eng J 2011;170(1):220–5.

[65] Easton ZM, Rogers M, Davis M, Wade J, Eick M, Bock E. Mitigation of sulfate reduction and nitrous oxide emission in denitrifying environments with amorphous iron oxide and biochar. Ecol Eng 2015;82:605–13.

[66] Lehmann J, Rillig MC, Thies J, Masiello CA, Hockaday WC, Crowley D. Biochar effects on soil biota—a review. Soil Biol Biochem 2011;43(9):1812–36.

[67] Maxwell BM, Birgand F, Schipper LA, Christianson LE, Tian S, Helmers MJ, et al. Increased duration of drying–rewetting cycles increases nitrate removal in woodchip bioreactors. Agric Environ Lett 2019;4(1):190028.

[68] Pluer WT, Morris CK, Todd Walter M, Geohring LD. Denitrifying bioreactor response during storm events. Agric Water Manage 2019;213:1109–15.

[69] Kijjanapanich P, Yaowakun Y. Enhancement of nitrate-removal efficiency using a combination of organic substrates and zero-valent iron as electron donors. J Environ Eng 2019;145(4):04019006.

[70] van der Lelie D, Taghavi S, McCorkle SM, Li LL, Malfatti SA, Monteleone D, et al. The metagenome of an anaerobic microbial community decomposing poplar wood chips. PLoS One 2012;7(5):e36740.

[71] Janusz G, Pawlik A, Sulej J, S´widerska-Burek U, Jarosz-Wilkołazka A, Paszczyn´ ski A. Lignin degradation: microorganisms, enzymes involved, genomes analysis and evolution. FEMS Microbiol Rev 2017;41(6):941–62.

[72] Ghane E, Feyereisen GW, Rosen CJ, Tschirner UW. Carbon quality of fouryear-old woodchips in a denitrification bed treating agricultural drainage water. Trans ASABE 2018;61(3):995–1000.

[73] Guo R, Li G, Jiang T, Schuchardt F, Chen T, Zhao Y, et al. Effect of aeration rate, C/N ratio and moisture content on the stability and maturity of compost. Bioresour Technol 2012;112:171–8.

[74] Ma Y, Hummel M, Määttänen M, Särkilahti A, Harlin A, Sixta H. Upcycling of waste paper and cardboard to textiles. Green Chem 2016;18(3):858–66.

[75] Wang X, Yang G, Feng Y, Ren G, Han X. Optimizing feeding composition and carbon–nitrogen ratios for improved methane yield during anaerobic codigestion of dairy, chicken manure and wheat straw. Bioresour Technol 2012;120:78–83.

[76] Worasuwannarak N, Sonobe T, Tanthapanichakoon W. Pyrolysis behaviors of rice straw, rice husk, and corncob by TG–MS technique. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis 2007;78(2):265–71.

[77] von Ahnen M, Aalto SL, Suurnäkki S, Tiirola M, Pedersen PB. Salinity affects nitrate removal and microbial composition of denitrifying woodchip bioreactors treating recirculating aquaculture system effluents. Aquaculture 2019;504:182–9.

[78] Halaburka BJ, LeFevre GH, Luthy RG. Evaluation of mechanistic models for nitrate removal in woodchip bioreactors. Environ Sci Technol 2017;51 (9):5156–64.

[79] Lepine C, Christianson L, Sharrer K, Summerfelt S. Optimizing hydraulic retention times in denitrifying woodchip bioreactors treating recirculating aquaculture system wastewater. J Environ Qual 2016;45(3):813–21.

[80] Hoover NL, Bhandari A, Soupir ML, Moorman TB. Woodchip denitrification bioreactors: impact of temperature and hydraulic retention time on nitrate removal. J Environ Qual 2016;45(3):803–12.

[81] Kuypers MMM, Marchant HK, Kartal B. The microbial nitrogen-cycling network. Nat Rev Microbiol 2018;16(5):263–76.

[82] Carlson HK, Lui LM, Price MN, Kazakov AE, Carr AV, Kuehl JV, et al. Selective carbon sources influence the end products of microbial nitrate respiration. ISME J 2020;14(8):2034–45.

[83] Kelso B, Smith RV, Laughlin RJ, Lennox SD. Dissimilatory nitrate reduction in anaerobic sediments leading to river nitrite accumulation. Appl Environ Microbiol 1997;63(12):4679–85.

[84] Parkes SD, Jolley DF, Wilson SR. Inorganic nitrogen transformations in the treatment of landfill leachate with a high ammonium load: a case study. Environ Monit Assess 2007;124(1–3):51–61.

[85] Hansen HCB, Guldberg S, Erbs M, Koch CB. Kinetics of nitrate reduction by green rusts-effects of interlayer anion and Fe(II):Fe(III) ratio. Appl Clay Sci 2001;18(1–2):81–91.

[86] Coby AJ, Picardal FW. Inhibition of NO3 - and NO2 - reduction by microbial Fe(III) reduction: evidence of a reaction between NO2 - and cell surface-bound Fe2+. Appl Environ Microbiol 2005;71(9):5267–74.

[87] Rancourt DG, Thibault PJ, Mavrocordatos D, Lamarche G. Hydrous ferric oxide precipitation in the presence of nonmetabolizing bacteria: constraints on the mechanism of a biotic effect. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 2005;69(3):553–77.

[88] Mulder A, van de Graaf AA, Robertson LA, Kuenen JG. Anaerobic ammonium oxidation discovered in a denitrifying fluidized bed reactor. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 1995;16(3):177–83.

[89] Cao S, Du R, Zhou Y. Coupling anammox with heterotrophic denitrification for enhanced nitrogen removal: a review. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol 2021;51 (19):2260–93.

[90] Kimura Y, Isaka K, Kazama F. Effects of inorganic carbon limitation on anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) activity. Bioresour Technol 2011;102(6):4390–4.

[91] Elgood Z, Robertson WD, Schiff SL, Elgood R. Nitrate removal and greenhouse gas production in a stream-bed denitrifying bioreactor. Ecol Eng 2010;36 (11):1575–80.

[92] Bock EM, Coleman BSL, Easton ZM. Effect of biochar, hydraulic residence time, and nutrient loading on greenhouse gas emission in laboratory-scale denitrifying bioreactors. Ecol Eng 2018;120:375–83.

[93] Wang Q, Jiang G, Ye L, Pijuan M, Yuan Z. Heterotrophic denitrification plays an important role in N2O production from nitritation reactors treating anaerobic sludge digestion liquor. Water Res 2014;62:202–10.

[94] Zhou W, Sun Y, Wu B, Zhang Y, Huang M, Miyanaga T, et al. Autotrophic denitrification for nitrate and nitrite removal using sulfur-limestone. J Environ Sci 2011;23(11):1761–9.

[95] Liu X, Xu J, Huang J, Huang M, Wang T, Bao S, et al. Bacteria-supported iron scraps for the removal of nitrate from low carbon-to-nitrogen ratio wastewater. RSC Adv 2019;9(6):3285–93.

[96] Pluer WT, Todd Walter M, Steinschneider S. Understanding complex flow pathways within lab-scale denitrifying bioreactors with a conservative tracer. Trans ASABE 2020;63(2):417–27.

[97] Christianson LE, Bhandari A, Hailers MJ. A practice-oriented review of woodchip bioreactors for subsurface agricultural drainage. Appl Eng Agric 2012;28(6):861–74.

[98] Di Capua F, Pirozzi F, Lens PNL, Esposito G. Electron donors for autotrophic denitrification. Chem Eng J 2019;362:922–37.

[99] Schipper LA, Cameron SC, Warneke S. Nitrate removal from three different effluents using large-scale denitrification beds. Ecol Eng 2010;36(11):1552–7.

[100] Tangsir S, Moazed H, Naseri AA, Hashemi Garmdareh SE, Broumand-nasab S, Bhatnagar A. Investigation on the performance of sugarcane bagasse as a new carbon source in two hydraulic dimensions of denitrification beds. J Clean Prod 2017;140(Pt 3):1176–81.

[101] Povilaitis A, Matikiene˙ J. Nitrate removal from tile drainage water: the performance of denitrifying woodchip bioreactors amended with activated carbon and flaxseed cake. Agric Water Manage 2020;229:105937.

[102] Miao S, Jin C, Liu R, Bai Y, Lan H, Liu H, et al. Carbon harvesting from organic liquid wastes for heterotrophic denitrification: feasibility evaluation and cost and emergy optimization. Resour Conserv Recycling 2020;160:104782.

Related Research