2014, Volume 16, Issue 8
Strategic Study of CAE >> 2014, Volume 16, Issue 8
Controversy on design science and competitiveness of design
1. School of Mechanical Engineering，Shanghai Jiao Tong University，Shanghai 200240，China；
2. School of Mechanical Engineering，Xi'an Jiaotong University，Xi'an 710049，China
Next Previous
Abstract
The controversy on ‘design science’ since the end of 19th century was reviewed. An analysis of the change of the cognition and idea of design in the ‘period of pre-industrial design’, ‘period of industrial design’ and ‘period of post-industrial design’ was given, especially in the period of industrial design. The change came following a rapid increase of the production capacity in meeting material needs. In fact, when the capacity could not meet material needs the competition of industrial production is scale expanding priority. Until an extremely expanding led to an overcapacity and a series of social problems the competition became to innovation priority. The change of competition paradigm changes the cognition and idea of design: from a rational and systematic design which ensured the large scale production of material products and followed the principles of material transformation into a creation leading design which tracks the desire of people in pursuing new things and better life which must meet simultaneously the material needs, psychological needs and social needs. Which design can make the innovation successful is decided by competition, not only the competition in market but also the competition in the social development process. The problem now is not that one who can or cannot design but the design with or without competitiveness. China is now on the way of mode transformation of economic development and it is very important to push forward the study of design science and make clear the change in design cognition and idea. The concepts of ‘competitive design’ and ‘inheriting design’ are suggested in the paper and discussed.
Keywords
design ; industrial design ; design science ; knowledge ; knowledge acquirement
Figures
图1
图2
图3
References
[ 1 ] 邹慧君. 设计的哲学思考[J]. 机械设计与研究，2013，29(1)：1- 4，9. link1
[ 2 ] 谢友柏. 设计科学中关于知识的研究——经济发展方式转变中 要考虑的重要问题[J]. 中国工程科学，2013，15(4)：14-22. link1
[ 3 ] Xie Youbai. Four basic laws in design science [J]. Engineering Sciences，2014，12(2)：2-8，28. link1
[ 4 ] 罗贯中. 三国演义[M]. 北京：人民文学出版社，1998.
[ 5 ] 宋应星. 天工开物[M]. 钟广言注释. 广东：广东人民出版社， 1976.
[ 6 ] Van Doesburg Theo，Van Eesteren Cornelis. The manifesto Ⅴ of group De Stijl：Towards a collective construction [J]. L’Effort Moderne Bulletin，1924(9)：15-16.
[ 7 ] Pahl Gerhard，Beitz Wolfgang，Feldhusen Jӧrg，et al. Engineering Design：A Systematic Approach [M]. London：SpringerVerlag London Limited，2007. link1
[ 8 ] Jensen Torben Elgaard，Andreasen Mogens Myrup. Design methods in practice：Beyond the‘systematic’approach of Pahl & Beitz [C]// Proceedings of the 11th International Design Conference DESIGN 2010. Cavtat- Dubrovnik，Croatia，2010.
[ 9 ] Alexander Christopher. Notes on the Synthesis of Form [M]. Cambridge，MA：Harvard University Press，1964. link1
[10] Jones John Christopher. How my thoughts about design methods have changed during the years [J]. Design Methods and Theories，1977，11(1)：45-62.
[11] Cross Nigel. Designerly ways of knowing：Design discipline versus design science [J]. Design Issues，2001，17(3)：49-55. link1
[12] Reich Yoram. Designing science [J]. Research in Engineering Design，2013，24(3)：215-218. link1
[13] Birkhofer Herbert，Lindemann Udo，Weber Christian. A view on design：The German perspective [J]. Journal of Mechanical Design，2012，134(11)：1-3. link1
[14] Gregory S A. Design Science [M]// Gregory S A，ed. The Design Method. London：Butterworth，1966：323-330.
[15] Simon Herbert A. The Sciences of the Artificial [M]. Cambridge，MA：MIT Press，1969.
[16] 谢友柏. 现代设计理论和方法的研究[J]. 机械工程学报， 2004，40(4)：1-9. link1
[17] 谢友柏. 现代设计理论中的若干基本概念[J]. 机械工程学报， 2007，43(11)：7-16. link1
[18] 汤姆·凯利，乔纳森·科特曼. 创新的艺术[M]. 李煜华，谢荣 华，译. 北京：中信出版社，2010.
[19] Nam Pyo Suh. 公理设计——发展与应用[M]. 谢友柏，袁小 阳，徐 华，等译. 北京：机械工业出版社，2004.
[20] 邹慧君，蒋祖华. 趣谈无所不在的设计[M]. 北京：科学出版 社，2010.
[21] 朱高峰. 全球化时代的中国制造[M]. 北京：社会科学文献出 版社，2003.
京公网安备 11010502051620号
