aCenter for Excellence in Regional Atmospheric Environment & Key Laboratory of Urban Pollutant Conversion, Institute of Urban Environment, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Xiamen 361021, China
bZhejiang Key Laboratory of Pollution Control for Port-Petrochemical Industry, Ningbo Urban Environment Observation and Research Station, Institute of Urban Environment, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo 315800, China
cState Key Joint Laboratory of Environment Simulation and Pollution Control, Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100085, China
dUniversity of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
eDepartment of Civil, Environmental and Construction Engineering, Catalysis Cluster for Renewable Energy and Chemical Transformations, NanoScience Technology Center, University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL 32816, USA
Catalytic activity and hydrothermal stability are both crucial for the application of the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 (NH3-SCR) catalyst in diesel vehicles. In this study, a tin (Sn)-modified Ce–Nb mixed-oxide catalyst was synthesized as an NH3-SCR catalyst for NOx emission control. After the introduction of Sn, both the NH3-SCR activity and the hydrothermal stability of the catalyst were remarkably promoted. Even after hydrothermal aging at 1000 °C, the developed Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst achieved more than 90% NOx conversion at 325–500 °C. Various methods, including N2-physisorption, X-ray diffraction, in-situ high-temperature X-ray diffraction, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, X-ray absorption fine-structure spectroscopy, temperature-programmed reduction of hydrogen, temperature-programmed desorption of ammonia, and density functional theory calculations were used to investigate the promotional effects induced by the Sn species. The characterization results showed that the addition of Sn not only promoted the formation of the Ce–Nb active phase but also improved its thermal stability, contributing to the excellent NH3-SCR performance and hydrothermal stability. This study provides an excellent sintering-resistance catalyst for the application of diesel engine NOx emission control.
Ying Zhu, Jingjing Liu, Guangzhi He, Shaohua Xie, Wenpo Shan, Zhihua Lian, Fudong Liu, Hong He.
Remarkable Enhancement of the Activity and Hydrothermal Stability of a CeO2-Based NH3-SCR Catalyst by Sn Modification.
Engineering, 2025, 48(5): 148-158 DOI:10.1016/j.eng.2024.02.011
Nitrogen oxides (NO and NO2, jointly referred to as NOx) emitted by diesel vehicles induce a series of environmental pollution problems, including acid rain, haze, and photochemical smog [1], [2], [3]. The selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 (NH3-SCR) is the most dominant technology for NOx removal from the exhaust of diesel vehicles [1], [4]. However, to meet Chinese VI and European VI diesel emission standards, an NH3-SCR catalytic converter is generally combined with an upstream diesel particulate filter (DPF) [5]. The active regeneration of the DPF typically exposes the NH3-SCR catalyst to high temperatures of up to 750–800 °C in the presence of water vapor [6]. Therefore, NH3-SCR catalysts for the purification of NOx in diesel exhaust should simultaneously possess excellent catalytic performance and superior hydrothermal stability [7].
Many types of catalysts have been applied to the NH3-SCR reaction, including oxides and zeolites based on transition metals and rare earth metals. At present, the dominant NH3-SCR catalyst for diesel vehicles is copper (Cu)-SSZ-13, a type of Cu-based small-pore zeolite with excellent catalytic activity and hydrothermal stability [8], [9], [10]. However, this type of catalyst cannot withstand hydrothermal aging at temperatures above 800 °C [11], [12], [13]. Among metal oxide catalysts, CeO2-based catalysts have been widely studied due to their unique redox ability, oxygen-storage capability, and acid–base properties [14], [15]. Nevertheless, pure CeO2 exhibits inferior NH3-SCR performance and poor thermal stability. Therefore, a series of additives have been introduced under the guidance of a high-dispersion close-coupling (HDCC) principle for the development of highly efficient NH3-SCR catalysts that involves the close coupling of redox and acid sites [1]. Niobium (Nb) compounds have been widely investigated as promoters for cerium oxide in the NH3-SCR reaction because the formation of Nb–OH and Nb=O not only increases the number of Brønsted and Lewis acid sites [16], [17], [18], [19] but also helps to increase the number of oxygen vacancies in the catalysts [19], [20]. In a previous study by our group, Ding et al. [20] found that the introduction of Nb improved the activity and hydrothermal stability of CeZrOx. However, the catalytic activity was less than 90% across the whole temperature range when the hydrothermal temperature increased to 850 °C, indicating that the role of Nb in promoting the hydrothermal stability of CeO2-based catalysts was still unsatisfactory. Therefore, the hydrothermal durability of CeO2-based catalysts still urgently needs to be enhanced.
SnO2 is an n-type semiconductor with a tetragonal structure and a high melting point of 1630 °C [21]. It has been widely used in catalytic materials because it possesses a large number of intrinsic defects [22], [23]. Leite et al. [24], [25] and Weber et al. [26] reported that the formation of an M–Sn solid solution (M = Y, La, Ce, or Nb) granted SnO2 excellent sintering resistance. Xu et al. [21], [27] and Zeng et al. [28] synthesized the above materials, which exhibited excellent thermal stability, and applied them to the field of carbon monoxide (CO) and methane (CH4) oxidation. Recently, we found that tin (Sn) stabilized a cerium–tungsten (Ce–W) oxide catalyst, and the obtained Ce–W–Sn ternary metal oxide catalyst realized more than 90% NOx conversion at 300–500 °C, even after severe hydrothermal aging at 1000 °C [29]. However, the promotional effects of the addition of Sn on NH3-SCR performance and hydrothermal stability still require further investigation, and the universality of the stability-promotion effect of Sn needs to be verified with other CeO2-based catalysts.
In this study, a prominent Ce–Sn–Nb ternary metal oxide catalyst with excellent NH3-SCR activity and superior hydrothermal stability was synthesized with the addition of Sn to a Ce–Nb oxide catalyst. The promotional effects of the Sn were systemically investigated using various methods, including N2-physisorption, X-ray diffraction (XRD), in-situ high-temperature X-ray diffraction (HTXRD), high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), X-ray absorption fine-structure (XAFS) spectroscopy, temperature-programmed reduction of hydrogen (H2-TPR), temperature-programmed desorption of ammonia (NH3-TPD), in-situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier-transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Sn is demonstrated to be an effective additive to improve the hydrothermal stability of a Ce–Sn–Nb catalyst.
2. Experimental section
2.1. Catalyst preparation and hydrothermal aging treatment
The Ce–Sn–Nb mixed oxide catalyst (denoted as Ce1SnaNb1Ox, where a = 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5, and 3.0) was synthesized by means of a co-precipitation method using NH3·H2O (25.0%–28.0%; Sinopharm Chemical Reagent Co., Ltd., China) as the precipitator. The required amounts of Ce(NO3)3·6H2O (≥ 99.0%; Sinopharm Chemical Reagent Co., Ltd.), SnCl4·5H2O (98.0%; Shanghai Aladdin Biochemical Technology Co., Ltd., China), and C10H5NbO20 (98.0%; Shanghai Macklin Biochemical Technology Co., Ltd., China) were dissolved together in deionized water. The details of the catalyst preparation are provided in Appendix A.
The selected samples, fresh Ce1Nb1Ox, and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalysts were hydrothermally aged at 800 °C for 16 h, 900 °C for 16 h, and 1000 °C for 3 h, respectively, in a feed gas of 10 volume percent (vol%) H2O/air condition to test the hydrothermal stability. The obtained samples were denoted as Ce1Nb1Ox-T and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox-T, where T represented the hydrothermal aging temperatures in °C.
2.2. Catalytic activity measurement
NH3-SCR activity tests of the as-obtained catalysts were carried out at atmospheric pressure in a fixed-bed flow reactor system, which was equipped with a quartz tube with an inner diameter of 6 mm. The reaction conditions were controlled as follows: 500 ppm NO, 500 ppm NH3, 5 vol% O2, 5 vol% H2O, and N2 balance, with a total flow rate of 500 mL·min−1 and a gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) of 100 000 h–1. Water vapor was fed into the airflow by adding N2 to the water in a thermostatic water bath. All the gas paths were covered with heating tape and aluminum foil to reduce heat loss and ensure that the reactants were completely vaporized. Reactant gases were adjusted using mass flowmeters before entering the reactor. The concentrations of the reactants and products were continuously monitored using a gas analyzer (Antaris IGS, Thermo Fisher Scientific, USA), which was equipped with a heated, low-volume multiple-path gas cell (2 m). Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectra were collected when the NH3-SCR reaction reached a steady state, and the NOx conversion and N2 selectivity were calculated using the following formulas:
where αNOx referred to the conversion of NOx; SN2 indicated the selectivity of N2; [NOx]in/out (x = 1 or 2) and [NH3]in/out referred to the concentration of NOx and NH3 in the inlet and outlet, respectively; [N2O]out indicated the N2O concentration in the outlet.
2.3. Catalyst characterization
The catalysts were characterized by means of N2-physisorption (BELSORP MAX, MicrotracBEL Corp., Japan), XRD (X’Pert PRO, PANalytical, the Netherlands), in-situ HTXRD (D8 Advance, Bruker, Germany), HRTEM (JEM-3200F, JEOL, Japan), XPS (AXIS Supra, Kratos Analytical Inc., UK), XAFS spectroscopy (7-BM Quick X-ray Absorption and Scattering (QAS) of the National Synchrotron Light Source II, Brookhaven National Laboratory, USA), H2-TPR (Autochem II 2920, Micromeritics, USA), and NH3-TPD (Autochem II 2920), as described in detail in Appendix A.
2.4. DFT calculations
Spin-polarized periodic DFT calculations were performed using the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) functional [30], as implemented in the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) [31]. Details are provided in Appendix A.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. NH3-SCR catalytic activity
The NOx conversion and N2 selectivity over the Ce1SnaNb1Ox catalysts are shown in Fig. S1 in Appendix A. After considering all the conditions, the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst with a Ce:Sn:Nb molar ratio of 1:2:1 was selected and tested for hydrothermal stability in this study. The NH3-SCR activities over the ternary Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox, unary (CeO2, SnO2, and Nb2O5), and binary (Ce1Nb1Ox, Ce1Sn2Ox, and Sn2Nb1Ox) catalysts at a GHSV of 100 000 h–1 are shown in Fig. 1(a). All the unary catalysts exhibited very low NH3-SCR activities, while the binary catalysts showed obviously improved activities. In fact, the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst already exhibited high NH3-SCR activity over a wide temperature range, indicating that the coupling of Ce and Nb oxides has synergistic effects for the NH3-SCR. After the addition of Sn, the low-temperature activity of the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst was further enhanced.
Interestingly, in addition to improving the NH3-SCR activity, the addition of Sn remarkably enhanced the hydrothermal stability of the catalyst. After hydrothermal aging at an extremely high temperature of 1000 °C, almost 100% NOx conversion was still obtained at 325–500 °C with the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst (Fig. 1(b)), accompanied by high N2 selectivity during the NH3-SCR reaction (Fig. S2 in Appendix A). On the other hand, hydrothermal aging induced a sharp decrease in the NH3-SCR activity of Ce1Nb1Ox, with almost no NOx conversion after aging at 900 and 1000 °C, indicating relatively low hydrothermal stability without the Sn doping. Therefore, the extraordinary hydrothermal stability of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst was determined to be due to the addition of Sn. For comparison, a commercial Cu-SSZ-13 catalyst was aged at 800 °C for 16 h under the same conditions as the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox, and the NH3-SCR activity was determined. The results showed that the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst possesses much better hydrothermal stability than the Cu-SSZ-13 catalyst, which has been commercially applied to diesel vehicles worldwide [32].
3.2. Textural properties
3.2.1. N2 physisorption analysis
The Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area (SBET) and total pore volume (Vtotal) of the fresh and aged Ce1Nb1Ox and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalysts were determined by means of nitrogen physisorption analysis; the results are listed in Table 1. The introduction of Sn resulted in some changes in the textural properties of the catalysts, with the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst exhibiting a higher specific surface area and total pore volume in comparison with the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst. After hydrothermal aging, it was evident that a significant decrease in SBET and Vtotal occurred for both of the Ce1Nb1Ox and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalysts. However, even when the hydrothermal aging temperature was increased to 1000 °C, Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox-1000 still possessed an SBET value of 16.2 m2·g−1 and a Vtotal value of 0.10 cm3·g−1, which were much higher than those of Ce1Nb1Ox-1000 (3.6 m2·g−1 and 0.01 cm3·g−1, respectively). This finding indicates that the formation of sintered particles of Ce1Nb1Ox during the hydrothermal aging was inhibited by the addition of Sn, which would be beneficial to the NH3-SCR reaction.
3.2.2. XRD analysis
To investigate the phase composition, we examined the XRD patterns of the catalysts (Fig. 2), which suggested that the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst is a polycrystalline oxide (Fig. 2(a)) consisting of a cubic CeO2 (c-CeO2) phase (Powder Diffraction File (PDF) 43-1002), an orthorhombic Nb2O5 (o-Nb2O5) phase (PDF 30-0873), and a tetragonal NbO2 (t-NbO2) phase (PDF 34-0898). A transition from the orthorhombic Nb2O5 phase to the monoclinic Nb2O5 (m-Nb2O5) phase (PDF 74-0298) appeared for the Ce1Nb1Ox-800 catalyst. As the hydrothermal aging temperature increased to 900 °C, aside from significant sintering, a phase transition from Nb2O5 and NbO2 to Ce0.333(NbO3) (PDF 70-4920) and CeNb5O14 (PDF 20-0267) was observed. When the hydrothermal aging temperature was further increased to 1000 °C, crystallization of the Ce0.333(NbO3) phase was clearly suppressed, while a new CeNbO4.08 (PDF 53-0754) phase and CeNbO4.25 (PDF 53-0755) phase appeared. As shown in Fig. 2(b), with the addition of Sn to the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst, a c-CeO2 phase and a tetragonal SnO2 (t-SnO2) phase were observed in the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox samples, while no characteristic diffraction peaks attributed to Nb species were detected, suggesting that the Nb species may exist in an amorphous or highly dispersed state, or may enter a lattice of Ce or Sn to form a solid solution. After hydrothermal aging at 800 °C, little change was observed. Upon further increasing the hydrothermal aging temperature, however, a new CeNbO4.25 phase with diffraction peaks at 29.4°, 31.4°, 43.5°, 46.6°, 53.9°, and 54.7° appeared. This phase became dominant on the catalyst that suffered from at an aging temperature of 1000 °C, indicating the occurrence of phase separation. In comparison with Ce1Nb1Ox, the crystal phase transition of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst was clearly inhibited by the Sn doping and the stability of its structure during hydrothermal aging was improved, which may account for the excellent hydrothermal stability of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst.
To further investigate the structure of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst, Rietveld refinement was used to calculate the lattice parameters and the mean crystallite size of each phase (Fig. 3; Table S1 and Fig. S3 in Appendix A). For the binary Ce1Sn2Ox catalyst, the cell volume of c-CeO2 (VCeO2) was less than that of the pure CeO2 phase, while the cell volume of t-SnO2 (VSnO2) was larger than that of the pure SnO2 phase, as listed in Table S1. Since the ionic radii of Ce4+, Sn4+, and Nb5+ are 0.87, 0.69, and 0.64 Å, respectively, the lattice contraction of c-CeO2 and the lattice expansion of t-SnO2 may be due to the partial incorporation of each other, resulting in the formation of c-Ce(Sn)O2 and t-Sn(Ce)O2 solid solutions, in line with previous studies [27], [28]. Nevertheless, the peak of SnO2(110) shifted toward a higher angle for the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst (Fig. S3(b)). At the same time, the VSnO2 of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst decreased compared with that of the Ce1Sn2Ox, whereas VCeO2 hardly changed. This may be caused by the incorporation of Nb5+ into the lattice of t-SnO2 to form a Sn–Nb solid solution structure. When the hydrothermal aging temperature was increased to 900 °C, the m-CeNbO4.25 structure was observed. It was also noted that lattice expansion of c-CeO2 occurred, which may be caused by the movement of some Sn species from the inner lattice to the surface and a transition from Ce4+ to Ce3+. Combining these findings with later XPS results, we deduced that part of the source of Ce3+ may be the formation of the CeNbO4.25 phase. Leite et al. [24], [25] revealed that the particle growth of SnO2 can be controlled by the addition of CeO2 and Nb2O5, resulting in high thermal stability. In the present work, the formation of Ce–Sn and Sn–Nb metastable solid solutions, as mentioned above, was beneficial for inhibiting the particle growth of SnO2 and stabilizing the active surface Ce and Nb species for the NH3-SCR reaction.
3.2.3. In-situ HTXRD analysis
An in-situ HTXRD experiment was carried out to investigate the phase transition and thermal stability of the catalysts (Fig. S4 in Appendix A); the most pronounced region of crystal phase transition (22.8°–34.4°) is shown in Fig. 4. When the temperature reached 850 °C, the CeNbO4.08 (42.9°) and Nb2O5 (24.3°) phases were observed for the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst. Upon further increasing the temperature to 900, 950, and 1000 °C, the new CeNb3O9 (23.1°, 25.7°, 27.9°, 31.3°, 32.6°, 46.4°, 48.3°, 52.4°, and 67.8°) and Nb2O5 (74.5°) phases were detected. A large number of Ce–Nb crystal phases were formed by solid–solid reactions accompanied by the release of oxygen (e.g., 2CeO2 + 3Nb2O5 → 6Ce1/3NbO3 + 1/2O2, 2/3CeO2 + 1/3CeNb3O9 → CeNbO4 + 1/6O2, t-CeNbO4 + δ/2O2 → m-CeNbO4+δ) [33], [34], which blocked the redox cycle of the Ce species through the process of oxygen release/storage, restraining the high-temperature performance [29]. For the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst, however, there was no crystalline phase change up to 950 °C. Nb2O5 with different crystal types (PDF 18-0911, 22-1196, and 32-0711) formed at 1000 °C and then completely disappeared when the temperature cooled down to room temperature. Meanwhile, a new CeNbO4.25 crystal phase was observed at room temperature. The Ce–Nb crystal phase did not form in the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst throughout the entire high-temperature experimental environment, indicating that the redox cycle of the catalyst was not blocked under such harsh heat treatment. Therefore, Sn-doping contributes to maintaining the redox cycle under high-temperature aging by preserving the dispersion of Ce–Nb species.
3.2.4. HRTEM analysis
HRTEM was used to explore the morphologies of the obtained catalysts (Fig. S5 in Appendix A). As shown in Figs. S5(a) and (e), the particle sizes of Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox were clearly much smaller than those of Ce1Nb1Ox. With an increase in the hydrothermal aging temperature, the particle sizes of Ce1Nb1Ox grew rapidly, while only mild particle growth occurred for Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox, even after hydrothermal aging at 1000 °C for 3 h (Figs. S5(b–d) and (f–h)). This finding indicated that the addition of Sn inhibited the grain growth of the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst through the formation of Ce–Sn and Sn–Nb solid solutions.
The energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) mapping of Ce, Nb, and oxygen (O)—with and without Sn—for the catalysts is illustrated in Fig. 5, Fig. 6. The Ce and Nb species of the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst visibly agglomerated after hydrothermal aging at 800 °C. When the hydrothermal aging temperature was increased further, this agglomeration became more serious. However, notably, the introduction of Sn restrained the agglomeration of Ce and Nb species in Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox to some extent, even at 1000 °C, accompanied by the high dispersion of Sn species. These results further verified that the addition of Sn would promote the sintering resistance of a catalyst during hydrothermal aging.
3.3. Composition and distribution
XPS measurements were carried out to clarify the surface compositions of fresh and hydrothermally aged Ce1Nb1Ox and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalysts (Fig. 7; Table S2 and Figs. S6 and S7 in Appendix A). As shown in Fig. 7, the Ce/(Ce + Sn + Nb) molar ratio decreased with an increase in the aging temperature. Moreover, the Nb/(Ce + Sn + Nb) ratio first increased and then gradually decreased. Surface enrichment of Nb species was observed after hydrothermal aging at 800 °C. When the hydrothermal aging temperature was further increased to 900 and 1000 °C, Ostwald ripening occurred in the Nb species [24], [25], [35]. During the Ostwald ripening process, dispersed Ce and Nb species may be in close contact and exist on the SnO2 surface under a humid 1000 °C atmosphere, serving as redox–acid coupled active sites (Ce–Nb active sites) for the NH3-SCR reaction, which might be responsible for the anti-sintering property of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst [29].
To further clarify the effect of Sn doping on hydrothermal stability, XAFS measurements were conducted to investigate the valance states of the Ce and Nb species and the local structure around the Nb species. The ratio of Ce3+/Ce calculated from the X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) spectra showed the same trend as the XPS results, confirming that the Sn doping and hydrothermal aging treatment increased the value of Ce3+/Ce (Figs. S8(a) and S9 in Appendix A). As shown in Fig. S8(b), the XANES results indicated that the coordination structures of the Nb species in the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst were transformed by severe hydrothermal aging, while those in the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst remained stable. Therefore, the addition of Sn stabilized the coordination structures of the Nb species in the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst.
In order to further investigate the local structure around the Nb atoms, we examined the magnitude of the k3-weighted Fourier-transform spectra (with a k range from 3.0 to 13.5 Å−1) for Nb2O5, Ce1Nb1Ox, Ce1Nb1Ox-900, Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox, and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox-900 (Fig. 8). There are two well-separated main peaks between 0.8–2.3 and 2.3–3.9 Å, respectively [36]. In the first coordination shell, the peaks in this region are ascribed to backscattering by the different oxygen atoms. The peaks found in the region of 2.3–3.9 Å are mainly due to the backscattering of Nb neighbors [37], [38]. The spectra of the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst showed a significant change after hydrothermal aging, indicating that both the first and the second coordination shells were severely influenced by the high-temperature hydrothermal aging treatment. The introduction of Sn also caused a change in the first and second coordination shells. However, for the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst, the spectra remained virtually unchanged after hydrothermal aging, proving once again that the doping with Sn stabilized the local structure around the Nb atoms to resist the hydrothermal aging.
3.4. Redox ability and surface species
An H2-TPR experiment was conducted to investigate the reducibility and oxygen mobility of all the obtained catalysts. As shown in Fig. 9(a), two H2 consumption peaks of CeO2 were observed at about 517 and 771 °C; these were assigned to the reduction of the surface Ce4+ to Ce3+ and of the bulk Ce4+ to Ce3+, respectively [39], [40], [41]. Two main peaks were observed for SnO2 at 200–400 and 400–900 °C, which were assigned to the consumption of surface oxygen species or partial Sn4+ to the Sn2+ state, and Sn2+ or Sn4+ to the metal Sn, respectively [39]. For the Nb2O5 sample, the reduction peaks at 476 and 861 °C were attributed to the reduction of surface and bulk Nb5+ to Nb4+, respectively [17], [20], [42]. For the Ce1Nb1Ox catalyst, two reduction peaks were observed, centered at about 588 and 714 °C, respectively. The reduction peak at 588 °C was assigned to the reduction of surface Ce4+ to Ce3+, while the peak at 714 °C was ascribed to the reduction of bulk CeO2 and Nb2O5[20]. After the addition of Sn, the reduction peaks of the surface and bulk oxygen species did not shift significantly. However, it is worth noting that the intensities of the reduction peaks for Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox were obviously higher than those for Ce1Nb1Ox, indicating that Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox possessed many more redox sites than Ce1Nb1Ox, in accordance with the XPS results.
The H2-TPR profiles of hydrothermally aged Ce1Nb1Ox catalysts are shown in Fig. 9(b). With an increase in the hydrothermal aging temperature below 900 °C, the reduction peaks shifted to higher reduction temperatures, and the integration of the H2-TPR curve gradually decreased. Unexpectedly, after hydrothermal aging at 1000 °C for 3 h, the reduction peaks exhibited a shift to a lower temperature. According to the HRTEM results, the Ce and Nb species agglomerated remarkably in the catalyst after hydrothermal aging at 1000 °C, which severely weakened the interaction between them. Therefore, the H2 reduction temperature of Ce1Nb1Ox-1000 was close to those of pure CeO2 and Nb2O5—that is, shifted to a lower temperature. As shown in Fig. 9(c), with an increase in the hydrothermal aging temperature, the reduction peaks of Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox gradually shifted to higher reduction temperatures, but the shapes of the peaks were maintained.
The H2 consumption of the as-prepared catalysts was calculated by means of the integration of the H2-TPR peaks (Fig. 9(d)). The H2 consumption of the fresh catalysts increased greatly after the introduction of Sn. According to the analysis of the Rietveld refinement, the formation of the c-Ce(Sn)O2 and t-Sn(Ce)O2 solid solutions caused lattice distortion, which led to the formation of oxygen vacancies and defects on the surface of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst [43]. For Ce1Nb1Ox, the redox ability was weakened when the hydrothermal aging temperature was increased. However, it is worth noting that there was no significant change in H2 consumption with an increase in the hydrothermal aging temperature for Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox. Taken together with the in-situ HTXRD results, these results suggest that Sn doping protects the redox sites of the catalyst from hydrothermal aging treatment, which may be an important reason for the high NH3-SCR activity being maintained after hydrothermal aging.
3.5. Surface acidity
NH3-TPD experiments were conducted to characterize the NH3 adsorption and activation capability of the catalysts (Fig. 10). As shown in Fig. 10(a), three overlapping peaks were detected for each sample. The peaks centered at 169 and 234 °C, corresponding to the ionic NH+4 bound to weak Brønsted acid sites (surface hydroxyls and structural defects). Because it is very difficult to distinguish NH4+ desorption on strong Brønsted acid sites and coordinated NH3 desorption on Lewis acid sites using NH3-TPD spectra [44], the peaks centered at 260, 328, 353, and 418 °C were ascribed to strong acid sites. In comparison with Ce1Nb1Ox, Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox exhibited an obvious increase in coordinated NH3 species at a higher temperature, and its total NH3 desorption clearly increased (Figs. 10(a) and (d)). This result implies that the Sn doping improves the strength and number of acid sites due to the synergetic effects between Sn, Ce, and Nb [45]. In addition, SnO2 possesses a certain number of acid sites, including Brønsted and Lewis acid sites, which could promote NH3 adsorption and activation on the surface of the catalyst [46], [47].
Figs. 10(b)–(d) show the NH3-TPD curves of hydrothermally aged Ce1Nb1Ox and hydrothermally aged Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox, as well as the total NH3 desorption amounts and specific NH3 desorption amounts normalized by the surface area of the as-prepared catalysts, respectively. With an increase in the hydrothermal aging temperature, the NH3 desorption of Ce1Nb1Ox decreased sharply, with almost no NH3 desorption being observed for catalysts aged at 900 and 1000 °C. In comparison, the decrease in the NH3 desorption of Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox as the hydrothermal aging temperature increased was much slower, and Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox-1000 still possessed a certain number of acid sites, even more than Ce1Nb1Ox-800, suggesting that the addition of Sn helped retain the strength and number of acid sites of the catalyst during the hydrothermal aging treatment. However, the numbers of acid sites on the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst still decreased after hydrothermal aging (Fig. 10(d)), which could be mainly due to the loss of specific surface area. There was no significant change in the numbers of acid sites when normalized to the specific surface area, demonstrating the excellent stability of the acid sites of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst.
3.6. DFT calculations
To study the stabilization of the NbOx, CeOx, or NbCeOx species on SnO2 surfaces, different optimized structures were derived using the DFT method. The formation energy of the NbOx, CeOx, or NbCeOx species on SnO2 surfaces () was defined as follows [48]:
where ENbOx/CeOx/NbCeOx-loaded_SnO2, ESnO2, ENb/Ce, and EO2 are the energies of the NbOx, CeOx, or NbCeOx species supported on the substrate, the SnO2 surface, the bulk Nb/Ce metal, and the gas-phase O2, respectively. The negative formation energy represents the stabilization of NbOx, CeOx, and NbCeOx species on the SnO2 surfaces. As shown in Fig. 11(a), the formation energies were –2.71, –8.27, and –12.75 eV for NbOx, CeOx, and NbCeOx on SnO2, respectively. This result suggests that the NbCeOx species are much more stable than the other species on the SnO2 surface. Given the surface molar ratios of the fresh and hydrothermally aged Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalysts from the XPS experiments, it was inferred that the dispersed CeOx and NbOx species tended to couple with each other to form efficient and stable NbCeOx species, working as redox–acid coupled active sites on the surface of the SnO2 to preserve the redox and acid sites during the hydrothermal aging.
In addition, the surface energies of SnO2 and the NbOx/CeOx/NbCeOx-loaded SnO2 surfaces ( and ) were calculated to determine the effect of surface NbOx, CeOx, and NbCeOx species on the structural stabilization. The and are respectively defined as follows [49]:
where A is the surface area of the slab, and , , and are the energies of the SnO2 surface, the SnO2 unit cell, and the NbOx, CeOx, or NbCeOx species supported on the SnO2 surface, respectively. From Fig. 11(b), the surface energy of the SnO2(110) crystal plane was predicted to be 0.10 eV·Å−2, which decreased to 0.05, 0.01, and 0.01 eV·Å−2, respectively, when there were NbOx, CeOx, and NbCeOx species on the surfaces; this indicates that the loading of NbOx, CeOx, and NbCeOx species significantly enhances the structural stabilization of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst.
4. Conclusions
In summary, a novel Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox ternary metal oxide catalyst with extraordinary hydrothermal stability was synthesized by means of a co-precipitation method for the NH3-SCR reaction. Even after being hydrothermally aged at an extremely high temperature of 1000 °C for 3 h, the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst still showed high NH3-SCR activity, with more than 90% NOx conversion in the range of 325–500 °C. It was shown that the addition of Sn to Ce1Nb1Ox resulted in a significant decrease in the particle size, enhancement of the specific surface area, and an increase in both the redox and acid sites, as well as the formation of efficient and stable NbCeOx active species on the surface of the t-SnO2 lattice. The formation of NbCeOx active species on the t-SnO2 surface contributed to the retention of redox sites and acid sites during hydrothermal aging treatment. In addition, the active species stabilized the structure of the catalyst against sintering. All these factors are responsible for the excellent NH3-SCR performance and hydrothermal stability of the Ce1Sn2Nb1Ox catalyst.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (52225004 and 22276202), the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2022YFC3701804), and the Youth Innovation Promotion Association of Chinese Academy of Sciences (2019045).
This research used beamline 7-BM (QAS) of the National Synchrotron Light Source II, a US Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science User Facility operated for the DOE Office of Science by Brookhaven National Laboratory under Contract No. DE-SC0012704.
ShanW, YuY, ZhangY, HeG, PengY, LiJ, et al.Theory and practice of metal oxide catalyst design for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3.Catal Today2021; 376:292-301.
[2]
HanL, CaiS, GaoM, HasegawaJ, WangP, ZhangJ, et al.Selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 by using novel catalysts: state of the art and future prospects.Chem Rev2019; 119(19):10916-10976.
[3]
PaolucciC, KhuranaI, ParekhAA, LiS, ShihAJ, LiH, et al.Dynamic multinuclear sites formed by mobilized copper ions in NOx selective catalytic reduction.Science2017; 357(6354):898-903.
[4]
HeG, LianZ, YuY, YangY, LiuK, ShiX, et al.Polymeric vanadyl species determine the low-temperature activity of V-based catalysts for the SCR of NOx with NH3.Sci Adv2018; 4(11):eaau4637.
[5]
KalghatgiG.Development of fuel/engine systems—the way forward to sustainable transport.Engineering2019; 5(3):510-518.
[6]
LiuS, LiuJ, LinQ, XuS, WangJ, XuH, et al.Solvent effects on the low-temperature NH3-SCR activity and hydrothermal stability of WO3/SiO2@CeZrOx catalyst.ACS Sustain Chem Eng2020; 8(35):13418-13429.
[7]
LiuS, LinQ, LiuJ, XuS, WangY, XuH, et al.Enhancement of the hydrothermal stability of WO3/Ce0.68Zr0.32O2 catalyst by silica modification for NH3-SCR.ACS Appl Energy Mater2020; 3(1):1161-1170.
[8]
BealeAM, GaoF, Lezcano-GonzalezI, PedenCHF, SzanyiJ.Recent advances in automotive catalysis for NOx emission control by small-pore microporous materials.Chem Soc Rev2015; 44(20):7371-7405.
[9]
WangJ, ZhaoH, HallerG, LiY.Recent advances in the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 on Cu-chabazite catalysts.Appl Catal B2017; 202:346-354.
[10]
ShanW, SongH.Catalysts for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 at low temperature.Catal Sci Technol2015; 5(9):4280-4288.
[11]
KimYJ, LeeJK, MinKM, HongSB, NamIS, ChoBK.Hydrothermal stability of CuSSZ13 for reducing NOx by NH3.J Catal2014; 311:447-457.
[12]
SchmiegSJ, OhSH, KimCH, BrownDB, LeeJH, PedenCHF, et al.Thermal durability of Cu-CHA NH3-SCR catalysts for diesel NOx reduction.Catal Today2012; 184(1):252-261.
[13]
ShanY, ShanW, ShiX, DuJ, YuY, HeH.A comparative study of the activity and hydrothermal stability of Al-rich Cu-SSZ-39 and Cu-SSZ-13.Appl Catal B2020; 264:118511.
[14]
ZhangT, QuR, SuW, LiJ.A novel Ce–Ta mixed oxide catalyst for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3.Appl Catal B, 176–1772015; 338-346.
[15]
VuongTH, RadnikJ, RabeahJ, BentrupU, SchneiderM, AtiaH, et al.Efficient VOx/Ce1–xTixO2 catalysts for low-temperature NH3-SCR: reaction mechanism and active sites assessed by in situ/operando spectroscopy.ACS Catal2017; 7(3):1693-1705.
[16]
MaZ, WuX, SiZ, WengD, MaJ, XuT.Impacts of niobia loading on active sites and surface acidity in NbOx/CeO2–ZrO2 NH3-SCR catalysts.Appl Catal B2015; 179:380-394.
[17]
QuR, GaoX, CenK, LiJ.Relationship between structure and performance of a novel cerium–niobium binary oxide catalyst for selective catalytic reduction of NO with NH3.Appl Catal B, 142–1432013; 290-297.
[18]
MaZ, WengD, WuX, SiZ, WangB.A novel Nb–Ce/WOx–TiO2 catalyst with high NH3-SCR activity and stability.Catal Commun2012; 27:97-100.
[19]
MaS, GaoW, YangZ, LinR, WangX, ZhuX, et al.Superior Ce–Nb–Ti oxide catalysts for selective catalytic reduction of NO with NH3.J Energy Inst2021; 94:73-84.
[20]
DingS, LiuF, ShiX, HeH.Promotional effect of Nb additive on the activity and hydrothermal stability for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3 over CeZrOx catalyst.Appl Catal B2016; 180:766-774.
[21]
XuX, LiuF, HanX, WuY, LiuW, ZhangR, et al.Elucidating the promotional effects of niobia on SnO2 for CO oxidation: developing an XRD extrapolation method to measure the lattice capacity of solid solutions.Catal Sci Technol2016; 6(14):5280-5291.
[22]
WangY, JiangX, XiaY.A solution-phase, precursor route to polycrystalline SnO2 nanowires that can be used for gas sensing under ambient conditions.J Am Chem Soc2003; 125(52):16176-16177.
[23]
FangC, ShiL, LiH, HuangL, ZhangJ, ZhangD.Creating hierarchically macro-/mesoporous Sn/CeO2 for the selective catalytic reduction of NO with NH3.RSC Adv2016; 6(82):78727-78736.
[24]
LeiteER, MacielAP, WeberIT, Lisboa-FilhoPN, LongoE, Paiva-SantosCO, et al.Development of metal oxide nanoparticles with high stability against particle growth using a metastable solid solution.Adv Mater2002; 14(12):905-908.
[25]
LeiteER, WeberIT, LongoE, VarelaJA.A new method to control particle size and particle size distribution of SnO2 nanoparticles for gas sensor applications.Adv Mater2000; 12(13):965-968.
[26]
WeberIT, MacielAP, Lisboa-FilhoPN, LongoE, LeiteER, Paiva-SantosCO, et al.Effects of synthesis and processing on supersaturated rare earth-doped nanometric SnO2 powders.Nano Lett2002; 2(9):969-973.
[27]
XuX, ZhangR, ZengX, HanX, LiY, LiuY, et al.Effects of La, Ce, and Y oxides on SnO2 catalysts for CO and CH4 oxidation.ChemCatChem2013; 5(7):2025-2036.
[28]
ZengX, ZhangR, XuX, WangX.Study on ceria-modified SnO2 for CO and CH4 oxidation.J Rare Earths2012; 30(10):1013-1019.
[29]
LiuJ, HeG, ShanW, YuY, HuoY, ZhangY, et al.Introducing tin to develop ternary metal oxides with excellent hydrothermal stability for NH3 selective catalytic reduction of NOx.Appl Catal B2021; 291:120125.
[30]
PerdewJP, BurkeK, ErnzerhofM.Generalized gradient approximation made simple.Phys Rev Lett1996; 77(18):3865-3868.
[31]
KresseG, FurthmüllerJ.Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set.Phys Rev B1996; 54(16):11169-11186.
[32]
ZhangY, WangH, ChenR.Improved high-temperature hydrothermal stability of Cu-SSZ-13 by an ammonium hexafluorosilicate treatment.RSC Adv2015; 5(83):67841-67848.
[33]
BridgesC, GreedanJE, BarbierJ.Structure of the defect perovskite Ce1/3NbO3: a redetermination by electron and neutron powder diffraction.Acta Cryst B2000; 56(2):183-188.
[34]
VullumF, GrandeT.Oxygen driven decomposition of CeNbO4 in pure oxygen.Chem Mater2008; 20(16):5434-5437.
[35]
MacielAP, Lisboa-FilhoPN, LeiteER, Paiva-SantosCO, SchreinerWH, ManietteY, et al.Microstructural and morphological analysis of pure and Ce-doped tin dioxide nanoparticles.J Eur Ceram Soc2003; 23(5):707-713.
[36]
MariniC, Diaz-RoviraAM, KennedyBJ, JosephB.Local structure around Nb site of a potential thermoelectric material La1/3NbO3 from temperature-dependent extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy.J Mater Eng Perform2018; 27(12):6322-6327.
[37]
TanakaT, YoshidaT, YoshidaH, AritaniH, FunabikiT, YoshidaS, et al.XAFS study of niobium oxide on alumina.Catal Today1996; 28(1–2):71-78.
[38]
CasapuM, KröcherO, MehringM, NachtegaalM, BorcaC, HarfoucheM, et al.Characterization of Nb-containing MnOx–CeO2 catalyst for low-temperature selective catalytic reduction of NO with NH3.J Phys Chem C2010; 114(21):9791-9801.
[39]
ZhangG, HanW, ZhaoH, ZongL, TangZ.Solvothermal synthesis of well-designed ceria–tin–titanium catalysts with enhanced catalytic performance for wide temperature NH3-SCR reaction.Appl Catal B2018; 226:117-126.
[40]
ZhangT, QiuF, ChangH, PengY, LiJ.Novel W-modified SnMnCeOx catalyst for the selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3.Catal Commun2017; 100:117-120.
[41]
ZhaoK, HanW, LuG, LuJ, TangZ, ZhenX.Promotion of redox and stability features of doped Ce–W–Ti for NH3-SCR reaction over a wide temperature range.Appl Surf Sci2016; 379:316-322.
[42]
StoDšić, BenniciS, RakiVć, AurouxA.CeO2–Nb2O5 mixed oxide catalysts: preparation, characterization and catalytic activity in fructose dehydration reaction.Catal Today2012; 192(1):160-168.
[43]
GongP, XieJ, ChengX, FangD, HeF, LiF, et al.Elucidate the promotional effects of Sn on Ce–Ti catalysts for NH3-SCR activity.J Energy Inst2020; 93(3):1053-1063.
[44]
ZhaoX, HuangL, LiH, HuH, HuX, ShiL, et al.Promotional effects of zirconium doped CeVO4 for the low-temperature selective catalytic reduction of NOx with NH3.Appl Catal B2016; 183:269-281.
[45]
YangB, ShenY, ZengY, LiB, ShenS, ZhuS.Effects of tin doping level on structure, acidity and catalytic performance of Ti–Ce–Ox catalyst for selective catalytic reduction of NO by ammonia.J Mol Catal A, 418–4192016; 138-145.
[46]
AbeeMW, CoxDF.NH3 chemisorption on stoichiometric and oxygen-deficient SnO2(110) surfaces.Surf Sci2002; 520(1–2):65-77.
[47]
KovalenkoVV, ZhukovaAA, RumyantsevaMN, GaskovAM, YushchenkoVV, IvanovaII, et al.Surface chemistry of nanocrystalline SnO2: effect of thermal treatment and additives.Sens Actuators B2007; 126(1):52-55.
[48]
SongI, LeeJ, LeeG, HanJW, KimDH.Chemisorption of NH3 on monomeric vanadium oxide supported on anatase TiO2: a combined DRIFT and DFT study.J Phys Chem C2018; 122(29):16674-16682.
[49]
TranR, XuZ, RadhakrishnanB, WinstonD, SunW, PerssonKA, et al.Surface energies of elemental crystals.Sci Data2016; 3(1):160080.