Radial Wellbore Cross-Layer Fracturing in Multi-Lithologic Superimposed Shale Oil Reservoirs: A Laboratory Study

Xiaoguang Wu, Zhongwei Huang, Tengda Long, Gensheng Li, Shouceng Tian, Haizhu Wang, Ruiyue Yang, Kun Li, Zikang Wang

Engineering ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2) : 188-211.

PDF(13694 KB)
PDF(13694 KB)
Engineering ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2) : 188-211. DOI: 10.1016/j.eng.2024.08.017
Research
Article

Radial Wellbore Cross-Layer Fracturing in Multi-Lithologic Superimposed Shale Oil Reservoirs: A Laboratory Study

Author information +
History +

Abstract

Medium-high maturity continental shale oil is one of the hydrocarbon resources with the most potential for successful development in China. Nevertheless, the unique geological conditions of a multi-lithologic superposition shield the vertical propagation of hydraulic fractures and limit the longitudinal reconstruction in reservoirs, posing a great challenge for large-scale volumetric fracturing. Radial wellbore cross-layer fracturing, which transforms the interaction between the hydraulic fractures and lithologic interface into longitudinal multilayer competitive initiation, could provide a potential solution for this engineering challenge. To determine the longitudinal propagation behaviors of fractures guided by radial wellbores, true triaxial fracturing experiments were performed on multilayer shale–sandstone samples, with a focus on the injection pressure response, fracture morphology, and cross-layer pattern. The effects of the radial borehole length L, vertical stress difference Kv, injection rate Q, and viscosity ν of the fracturing fluid were analyzed. The results indicate that radial wellbores can greatly facilitate fracture initiation and cross-layer propagation. Unlike conventional hydraulic fracturing, there are two distinct fracture propagation patterns in radial wellbore fracturing: cross-layering and skip-layering. The fracture height guided by a radial wellbore is positively correlated with Kv, Q, and ν. Increasing these parameters causes a shift in the fracture initiation from a single root to an asynchronous root/toe end and can improve the cross-layer propagation capacity. Critical parameter thresholds exist for fracture propagation through and across interlayers under the guidance of radial boreholes. A parameter combination of critical cross-layering/skip-layering or alternating displacement/viscosity is recommended to simultaneously improve the fracture height and degree of lateral activation. The degree of correlation of different parameters with the vertical fracture height can be written as L > Q/ν > Kv. Increasing the radial wellbore length can effectively facilitate fracture cross-/skip-layer propagation and reduce the critical threshold of injection parameters, which is conducive to maximizing the stimulated reservoir volume.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Hydraulic fracturing / Continental shale oil / Multi-lithologic superimposed reservoir / Radial wellbore fracturing / Cross-layer

Cite this article

Download citation ▾
Xiaoguang Wu, Zhongwei Huang, Tengda Long, Gensheng Li, Shouceng Tian, Haizhu Wang, Ruiyue Yang, Kun Li, Zikang Wang. Radial Wellbore Cross-Layer Fracturing in Multi-Lithologic Superimposed Shale Oil Reservoirs: A Laboratory Study. Engineering, 2025, 45(2): 188‒211 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eng.2024.08.017

References

[1]
Zhao W, Hu S, Hou L, Yang T, Li X, Guo B, et al.Types and resource potential of continental shale oil in China and its boundary with tight oil.Pet Explor Dev 2020; 47(1):1-11.
[2]
Li G, Xian C, Liu H.A “one engine with six gears” system engineering methodology for the economic development of unconventional oil and gas in China.Engineering 2022; 18:105-115.
[3]
Jia C, Zheng M, Zhang Y.Unconventional hydrocarbon resources in China and the prospect of exploration and development.Pet Explor Dev 2012; 39(2):139-146.
[4]
He W, Zhu R, Cui B, Zhuang S, Meng Q, Bai B, et al.The geoscience frontier of Gulong shale oil: revealing the role of continental shale from oil generation to production.Engineering 2023; 28:79-92.
[5]
Davis LA.The shale oil and gas revolution.Engineering 2018; 4(4):438-439.
[6]
Lei Q, Weng D, Xiong S, Liu H, Guan B, Deng Q, et al.Progress and development directions of shale oil reservoir stimulation technology of China National Petroleum Corporation.Pet Explor Dev 2021; 48(5):1198-1207.
[7]
Zou C.Unconventional petroleum geology. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2017)
[8]
Zou C, Qiu Z, Zhang J, Li Z, Wei H, Liu B, et al.Unconventional petroleum sedimentology: a key to understanding unconventional hydrocarbon accumulation.Engineering 2022; 18:62-78.
[9]
Li L, Huang B, Li Y, Hu R.Multi-scale modeling of shale laminas and fracture networks in the Yanchang Formation, Southern Ordos Basin, China.Eng Geol 2018; 243:231-240.
[10]
Li G, Huang Z, Tian S, Shen Z.Research and application of water jet technology in well completion and stimulation in China.Pet Sci 2010; 7:239-244.
[11]
Balch RS, Ruan T, Savage M, Harvard J.Field testing and validation of a mechanical alternative to radial jet drilling for improving recovery in mature oil wells. In: Proceedings of SPE Western Regional Meeting; 2016 May 23–26; Anchorage, AK, USA. Richardson: OnePetro; 2016.
[12]
Yang RY, Li GS, Qin XZ, Huang ZW, Li JB, Sheng M, et al.Productivity enhancement in multilayered coalbed methane reservoirs by radial borehole fracturing.Pet Sci 2022; 19(6):2844-2866.
[13]
Ouchi H, Foster JT, Sharma MM.Effect of reservoir heterogeneity on the vertical migration of hydraulic fractures.J Pet Sci Eng 2017; 151:384-408.
[14]
Oyedokun O, Schubert J.A quick and energy consistent analytical method for predicting hydraulic fracture propagation through heterogeneous layered media and formations with natural fractures: the use of an effective fracture toughness.J Nat Gas Sci Eng 2017; 44:351-364.
[15]
Cao P, Liu T, Pu C, Lin H.Crack propagation and coalescence of brittle rock-like specimens with pre-existing cracks in compression.Eng Geol 2015; 187:113-121.
[16]
Liu K, Sheng JJ.Experimental study of the effect of stress anisotropy on fracture propagation in Eagle Ford shale under water imbibition.Eng Geo 2019; 249:13-22.
[17]
Wasantha PLP, Ranjith PG, Zhang QB, Xu T.Do joint geometrical properties influence the fracturing behaviour of jointed rock? An investigation through joint orientation.Geomech Geophys Geo Energ Geo Resour 2015; 1:3-14.
[18]
AlTammar MJ, Sharma MM.Effect of geological layer properties on hydraulic fracture initiation and propagation: an experimental study. In: Proceedings of SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference and Exhibition; 2017 Jan 24–26; The Woodlands, TX, USA. Richardson: OnePetro; 2017.
[19]
AlTammar MJ, Agrawal S, Sharma MM.Effect of geological layer properties on hydraulic-fracture initiation and propagation: an experimental study.SPE J 2019; 24:757-794.
[20]
Jebli M, Jamin F, Malachanne E, Garcia-Diaz E, El Youssoufi MS.Experimental characterization of mechanical properties of the cement-aggregate interface in concrete.Constr Build Mater 2018; 161:16-25.
[21]
Chang X, Shan Y, Zhang Z, Tang C, Ru Z.Behavior of propagating fracture at bedding interface in layered rocks.Eng Geol 2015; 197:33-41.
[22]
Cai M, Wang W, Wang X, Zhao L, Zhang H.Characteristics of hydraulic fracture penetration behavior in tight oil with multi-layer reservoirs.Energy Rep 2023; 10:2090-2102.
[23]
Llanos EM, Jeffrey RG, Hillis R, Zhang X.Hydraulic fracture propagation through an orthogonal discontinuity: a laboratory, analytical and numerical study.Rock Mech Rock Eng 2017; 50:2101-2118.
[24]
Zhuang X, Zhou S, Sheng M, Li G.On the hydraulic fracturing in naturally-layered porous media using the phase field method.Eng Geol 2020; 266:105306.
[25]
Gross MR, Eyal Y.Throughgoing fractures in layered carbonate rocks.GSA Bull 2007; 119(11–12):1387-1404.
[26]
Zou Y, Shi S, Zhang S, Li J, Wang F, Wang J, et al.Hydraulic fracture geometry and proppant distribution in thin interbedded shale oil reservoirs.Pet Explor Dev 2022; 49(5):1185-1194.
[27]
Zhang J, Li Y, Pan Y, Wang X, Yan M, Shi X, et al.Experiments and analysis on the influence of multiple closed cemented natural fractures on hydraulic fracture propagation in a tight sandstone reservoir.Eng Geol 2021; 281:105981.
[28]
Wan L, Hou B, Meng H, Cang Z, Muhadasi Y, Chen M.Experimental investigation of fracture initiation position and fluid viscosity effect in multi-layered coal strata.J Pet Sci Eng 2019; 182:106310.
[29]
Tan P, Jin Y, Han K, Hou B, Chen M, Guo X, et al.Analysis of hydraulic fracture initiation and vertical propagation behavior in laminated shale formation.Fuel 2017; 206:482-493.
[30]
Xing P, Yoshioka K, Adachi J, El-Fayoumi A, Damjanac B, Bunger AP.Lattice simulation of laboratory hydraulic fracture containment in layered reservoirs.Comput Geotech 2018; 100:62-75.
[31]
Cong Z, Li Y, Tang J, Martyushev DA, Yang F.Numerical simulation of hydraulic fracture height layer-through propagation based on three-dimensional lattice method.Eng Fract Mech 2022; 264:108331.
[32]
Hadei MR, Veiskarami A.An experimental investigation of hydraulic fracturing of stratified rocks.Bull Eng Geol Environ 2021; 80:491-506.
[33]
Wan L, Hou B, Tan P, Chang Z, Muhadasi Y.Observing the effects of transition zone properties on fracture vertical propagation behavior for coal measure strata.J Struct Geol 2019; 126:69-82.
[34]
Wang Y, Hou B, Wang D, Jia Z.Features of fracture height propagation in cross-layer fracturing of shale oil reservoirs.Pet Explor Dev 2021; 48(2):469-479.
[35]
Yong Y, Guo Z, Tian S, Wang T, Sheng M, Liao L.Fracture geometries and breakdown pressures of multi-branch radial borehole fracturing influenced by horizontal stress difference. In: Proceedings of 57th US Rock Mechanics/Geomechanics Symposium; 2023 Jun 25–28; Atlanta, GE, USA. Richardson: OnePetro; 2023.
[36]
Guo T, Qu Z, Gong D, Lei X, Liu M.Numerical simulation of directional propagation of hydraulic fracture guided by vertical multi-radial boreholes.J Na Gas Sc Eng 2016; 35:175-188.
[37]
Guo Z, Tian S, Liu Q, Ma L, Yong Y, Yang R.Experimental investigation on the breakdown pressure and fracture propagation of radial borehole fracturing.J Pet Sci Eng 2022; 208:109169.
[38]
Liu Q, Tian S, Li G, Sheng M, Li X, Wang T, et al.An analytical model for fracture initiation from radial lateral borehole.J Pet Sci Eng 2018; 164:206-218.
[39]
Dai JC, Wang TY, Weng JT, Tian KJ, Zhu LY, Li GS.CO2 flooding in shale oil reservoir with radial borehole fracturing for CO2 storage and enhanced oil recovery.Pet Sci 2024; 21(1):519-534.
[40]
He JC, Zhang KS, Liu HB, Tang MR, Zheng XL, Zhang GQ.Laboratory investigation on hydraulic fracture propagation in sandstone–mudstone–shale layers.Pet Sci 2022; 19(4):1664-1673.
[41]
Zheng G, Xu W, Etiope G, Ma X, Liang S, Fan Q, et al.Hydrocarbon seeps in petroliferous basins in China: a first inventory.J Asian Earth Sci 2018; 151:269-284.
[42]
Cao S, Ma J, Zhang L.Quantitative reconstruction of Early Cretaceous dune morphology in the Ordos paleo-desert and its paleoclimatic implications.Front Earth Sci 2023; 11:1142034.
[43]
De Pater CJ, Cleary MP, Quinn TS, Barr DT, Johnson DE, Weijers L.Experimental verification of dimensional analysis for hydraulic fracturing.SPE Prod Facilities 1994; 9(04):230-238.
[44]
Liu G, Pang F, Chen Z.Development of scaling laws for hydraulic fracture simulation tests.J Univ Pet China 2000; 24(5):45-48.
[45]
Yang R, Hong C, Liu W, Wu X, Wang T, Huang Z.Non-contaminating cryogenic fluid access to high-temperature resources: liquid nitrogen fracturing in a lab-scale enhanced geothermal system.Renewable Energy 2021; 165(1):125-138.
[46]
Peaceman DW.Interpretation of well-block pressures in numerical reservoir simulation with nonsquare grid blocks and anisotropic permeability.SPE J 1983; 23(3):531-543.
[47]
Li L, Lee SH.Efficient field-scale simulation of black oil in a naturally fractured reservoir through discrete fracture networks and homogenized media.SPE Res Eval Eng 2008; 11(4):750-758.
[48]
Moinfar A, Varavei A, Sepehrnoori K, Johns RT.Development of an efficient embedded discrete fracture model for 3D compositional reservoir simulation in fractured reservoirs.SPE J 2013; 19(2):289-303.
[49]
Xu Y, Filho JSC, Yu W, Sepehrnoori K.Discrete-fracture modeling of complex hydraulic-fracture geometries in reservoir simulators.SPE Res Eval Eng 2017; 20(2):403-422.
[50]
Figueiredo B, Tsang CF, Rutqvist J, Niemi A.The effects of nearby fractures on hydraulically induced fracture propagation and permeability changes.Eng Geol 2017; 228:197-213.
[51]
Fu J, Li S, Guo Q, Guo W, Zhou X, Liu J.Enrichment conditions and favorable area optimization of continental shale oil in Ordos Basin.Acta Pet Sin 2022; 43(12):1702-1716.
[52]
He Y, Li Z, Fan J, Zhang C, Zhang X, Ma B.Optimization technique of development well pattern of shale oil in Ordos Basin and its application: a case study of Qingcheng oilfield.Acta Pet Sin 2024; 45(4):683-697.
[53]
DaneshyA A.Hydraulic fracture propagation in the presence of planes of weakness. In: Proceedings of SPE European Spring Meeting; 1974 May 29–30; Amsterdam, the Netherlands. Richardson: OnePetro; 1974.
[54]
Gong DG, Qu ZQ, Guo TK, Tian Y, Tian KH.Variation rules of fracture initiation pressure and fracture starting point of hydraulic fracture in radial well.J Pet Sci Eng 2018; 140:41-56.
[55]
Clifton RJ, Abou-Sayed AS.On The computation of the three-dimensional geometry of hydraulic fractures. In: Proceedings of Symposium on Low Permeability Gas Reservoirs; 1979 May 20–22; Denver, CO, USA. Richardson: OnePetro; 1979.
[56]
Tsvetkov VY.Correlative analysis and opposition variables.Eur J Nat His 2014; 1:56-58.
[57]
Zhu W, Chen Z, Yang Y, Gong W, Wang M.Impacts of T-type intersections on the connectivity and flow in complex two-dimensional fracture networks.Eng Geol 2023; 320:107122.
[58]
Li Y, Hu W, Wei S, Li L, Zhang Z, Song S.Influence of preexisting discontinuities on hydraulic fracture complexity in a naturally fractured reservoir.Eng Geol 2022; 311:106919.
[59]
Douma LANR, Regelink JA, Bertotti G, Boersma QD, Barnhoorn A.The mechanical contrast between layers controls fracture containment in layered rocks.J Struct Geol 2019; 127:103856.
[60]
Liu Z, Jin Y, Chen M, Hou B.Analysis of non-planar multi-fracture propagation from layered-formation inclined-well hydraulic fracturing.Rock Mech Rock Eng 2016; 49:1747-1758.
AI Summary AI Mindmap
PDF(13694 KB)

Accesses

Citations

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/