A Comparative Evaluation of Indoor Transmission-Risk Assessment Metrics for Infectious Diseases

Inseok Yoon; Changbum Ahn; Seungjun Ahn; Bogyeong Lee; Jongjik Lee; Moonseo Park

doi:10.1016/j.eng.2024.11.029

PDF(1169 KB)

Engineering ›› 2025, Vol. 46 ›› Issue (3) : 306-315. DOI: 10.1016/j.eng.2024.11.029

Research

Article

A Comparative Evaluation of Indoor Transmission-Risk Assessment Metrics for Infectious Diseases

Author information +

History +

Abstract

Governments worldwide have implemented non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to control the spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), and it is crucial to accurately assess the effectiveness of such measures. Many studies have quantified the risk of infection transmission and used simulations to compare the risk before and after the implementation of NPIs to judge policies’ effectiveness. However, the choice of metric used to quantify the risk can lead to different conclusions regarding the effectiveness of a policy. In this study, we analyze the correlation between different transmission-risk metrics, pedestrian environments, and types of infectious diseases using simulation-generated data. Our findings reveal conflicting results among five different metric types in specific environments. More specifically, we observe that, when the randomness of pedestrian trajectories in indoor spaces is low, the closeness centrality exhibits a higher correlation coefficient with infection-based metrics than with contact-based metrics. Furthermore, even within the same pedestrian environment, the likelihood of discrepancies between infection-based metrics and other metrics increases for infectious diseases with low transmission rates. These results highlight the variability in the measured effectiveness of NPIs depending on the chosen metric. To evaluate NPIs accurately, facility managers should consider the type of facility and infectious disease and not solely rely on a single metric. This study provides a simulation model as a tool for future research and improves the reliability of pedestrian-simulation-based NPI effectiveness analysis methods.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Pandemic / Pedestrian simulation / Infectious transmission risk / Non-pharmaceutical interventions

Cite this article

EndNote

Ris (Procite)

Bibtex

Download citation ▾

Inseok Yoon, Changbum Ahn, Seungjun Ahn, Bogyeong Lee, Jongjik Lee, Moonseo Park. A Comparative Evaluation of Indoor Transmission-Risk Assessment Metrics for Infectious Diseases. Engineering, 2025, 46(3): 306‒315 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eng.2024.11.029

References

Publishing order | Descend order by publishing year | Descend order by cited within

[1]	Meyer BH, Prescott B, Sheng XS.The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on business expectations.Int J Forecast 2022; 38(2):529-544.

[2]	Falk G, Carter JA, Nivvhitta IA, Nyhof EC, Romero PD.Unemployment rates during the COVID-19 pandemic.Report. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service; 2020.

[3]	Panneer S, Kantamaneni K, Akkayasamy VS, Susairaj AX, Panda PK, Acharya SS, et al.The great lockdown in the wake of COVID-19 and its implications: lessons for low and middle-income countries.Int J Environ Res Public Health 2022; 19(1):610.

[4]	Lipton A, de Prado ML.Mitigation strategies for COVID-19: lessons from the K-SEIR model calibrated to the observable data.J Risk Financ Manag 2022; 15(6):248.

[5]	Woodhouse MJ, Aspinall WP, Sparks SR, Brooks-Pollock E, Relton C.Analysis of alternative COVID-19 mitigation measures in school classrooms: an agent-based model of SARS-CoV-2 transmission.R Soc Open Sci 2022; 9(8):211985.

[6]	Zafarnejad R, Griffin PM.Assessing school-based policy actions for COVID-19: an agent-based analysis of incremental infection risk.Comput Biol Med 2021; 134:104518.

[7]	Alam MJ, Habib MA, Holmes D.Pedestrian movement simulation for an airport considering social distancing strategy.Transp Res Interdiscip Perspect 2022; 13:100527.

[8]	Sparnaaij M, Yuan Y, Daamen W, Duives DC.A novel activity choice and scheduling model to model activity schedules of customers and staff in Dutch restaurants.2022. ArXiv220406775.

[9]	Wang J, Tang H, Wang J, Zhong Z.An agent-based study on the airborne transmission risk of infectious disease in a fever clinic during COVID-19 pandemic.Build Environ 2022; 218:109118.

[10]	Chen P, Zhang D, Liu J, Jian IY.Assessing personal exposure to COVID-19 transmission in public indoor spaces based on fine-grained trajectory data: a simulation study.Build Environ 2022; 218:109153.

[11]	Gunaratne C, Reyes R, Hemberg E, O UM’Reilly.Evaluating efficacy of indoor non-pharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 outbreaks with a coupled spatial-SIR agent-based simulation framework.Sci Rep 2022; 12(1):6202.

[12]	Jones NR, Qureshi ZU, Temple RJ, Larwood JP, Greenhalgh T, Bourouiba L.Two metres or one: what is the evidence for physical distancing in COVID-19?.BMJ 2020; 370:m3223.

[13]	Islam MT, Jain S, Chen Y, Chowdhury BDB, Son YJ.An agent-based simulation model to evaluate contacts, layout, and policies in entrance, exit, and seating in indoor activities under a pandemic situation.IEEE Trans Autom Sci Eng 2021; 19(2):603-619.

[14]	Darabi A, Siami M.Centrality in epidemic networks with time-delay: a decision-support framework for epidemic containment.In: Proceedings of the 2021 American Control Conference (ACC); 2021 May 25–28; virtual event. New York City: IEEE; 2021. p. 3062–7.

[15]	Shen B, Guan T, Ma J, Yang L, Liu Y.Social network research hotspots and trends in public health: a bibliometric and visual analysis.Public Health Pract 2021; 2:100155.

[16]	Jo W, Chang D, You M, Ghim GH.A social network analysis of the spread of COVID-19 in South Korea and policy implications.Sci Rep 2021; 11(1):8581.

[17]	Chan LYH, Yuan B, Convertino M.COVID-19 non-pharmaceutical intervention portfolio effectiveness and risk communication predominance.Sci Rep 2021; 11(1):10605.

[18]	Perra N.Non-pharmaceutical interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic: a review.Phys Rep 2021; 913:1-52.

[19]	Loades ME, Chatburn E, Sweeney NH, Reynolds S, Shafran R, Brigden A, et al.Rapid systematic review: the impact of social isolation and loneliness on the mental health of children and adolescents in the context of COVID-19.J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2020; 59(11):1218-1239.

[20]	Engzell P, Frey A, Verhagen MD.Learning loss due to school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2021; 118(17):e2022376118.

[21]	Kröger M, Schlickeiser R.Analytical solution of the SIR-model for the temporal evolution of epidemics—part A: time-independent reproduction factor.J Phys Math Theor 2020; 53(50):505601.

[22]	Schlickeiser R, Kröger M.Analytical solution of the SIR-model for the temporal evolution of epidemics—part B: semi-time case.J Phys Math Theor 2021; 54(17):175601.

[23]	Gerlee P, Karlsson J, Fritzell I, Brezicka T, Spreco A, Timpka T, et al.Predicting regional COVID-19 hospital admissions in Sweden using mobility data.Sci Rep 2021; 11(1):24171.

[24]	Lee B, Ahn S, Ahn CR.Understanding occupants’ physical distancing behavior for safer facility operation under COVID-19: in the context of educational facilities.J Manage Eng 2021; 38(3):04022007.

[25]	Lee B, Ahn C.Agent-based simulation to predict occupants’ physical distancing behaviors in educational buildings.In: Proceedings of the 2021 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC); 2021 Dec 15–17; Phoenix, AZ, USA. New York City: IEEE; 2021. p. 1–9.

[26]	Vermuyten H, Beli Jën, De Boeck L, Reniers G, Wauters T.A review of optimisation models for pedestrian evacuation and design problems.Saf Sci 2016; 87:167-178.

[27]	Tatapudi H, Das TK.Impact of school reopening on pandemic spread: a case study using an agent-based model for COVID-19.Infect Dis Model 2021; 6:839-847.

[28]	Li CY, Yin J.A pedestrian-based model for simulating COVID-19 transmission on college campus.Transp Transp Sci 2023; 19(01):2005182.

[29]	Rojas-Galeano S.Impact of personal protection habits on the spread of pandemics: insights from an agent-based model.Sci World J 2021; 1:666654.

[30]	Gouda M, Fan J, Luc K, Ibrahim S, El-Basyouny K.Effect of redesigning public shared space amid the COVID-19 pandemic on physical distancing and traffic safety.J Transp Eng Part Syst 2021; 147(11):04021077.

[31]	Pan J, Cho TY, Bardhan R.Redesigning the working space for social distancing: modelling the movement in an open-plan office.In: Proceedings of the CIBSE Technical Symposium 2021; 2021 Jul 13–14; virtual event. London: The Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers (CIBSE); 2021.

[32]	Ugail H, Aggarwal R, Iglesias A, Howard N, Campuzano A, Suárez P, et al.Social distancing enhanced automated optimal design of physical spaces in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.Sustain Cities Soc 2021; 68:102791.

[33]	Xiao Y, Yang M, Zhu Z, Yang H, Zhang L, Ghader S.Modeling indoor-level non-pharmaceutical interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic: a pedestrian dynamics-based microscopic simulation approach.Transp Policy 2021; 109:12-23.

[34]	Romano V, Duboscq J, Sarabian C, Thomas E, Sueur C, MacIntosh AJ.Modeling infection transmission in primate networks to predict centrality‐based risk.Am J Primatol 2016; 78(7):767-779.

[35]	Mahdizadeh Gharakhanlou N, Hooshangi N.Spatio-temporal simulation of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak using the agent-based modeling approach (case study: Urmia, Iran).Inform Med Unlocked 2020; 20:100403.

[36]	Shamil M, Farheen F, Ibtehaz N, Khan IM, Rahman MS.An agent-based modeling of COVID-19: validation, analysis, and recommendations.Cognit Comput 2021; 16:1723-1734.

[37]	He S, Peng Y, Sun K.SEIR modeling of the COVID-19 and its dynamics.Nonlinear Dyn 2020; 101(3):1667-1680.

[38]	Teng YW, Shi Y, Yang D, Lee WC, Su P, Lu YL, et al.Epidemic spread optimization for disease containment with NPIs and vaccination.In: Proceeding of the 2022 IEEE 38th International Conference on Data Engineering (ICDE); 2022 May 9–12; Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. New York City: 2022. p. 2845–58.

[39]	Gugole F, Coffeng LE, Edeling W, Sanderse B, De Vlas SJ, Crommelin D.Uncertainty quantification and sensitivity analysis of COVID-19 exit strategies in an individual-based transmission model.PLoS Comput Biol 2021; 17(9):e1009355.

[40]	Jensen BC, Engsig-Karup AP, Knudsen K.Efficient uncertainty quantification and variance-based sensitivity analysis in epidemic modelling using polynomial chaos.Math Model Nat Phenom 2022; 17:8.

[41]	Al Handawi K, Kokkolaras M.Optimization of infectious disease prevention and control policies using artificial life.IEEE Trans Emerg Top Comput Intell 2022; 6(1):26-40.

[42]	Wandelt S, Sun X, Zanin M, Havlin S.QRE: quick robustness estimation for large complex networks.Future Gener Comput Syst 2018; 83:413-424.

[43]	Wu H, Wu C, Lu Q, Ding Z, Xue M, Lin J.Spatiotemporal analysis and the characteristics of the case transmission network of 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Zhejiang Province, China.PLoS One 2021; 16(9):e0257587.

[44]	Sun X, Wandelt S, Zhang A.How did COVID-19 impact air transportation? A first peek through the lens of complex networks.J Air Transp Manage 2020; 89:101928.

[45]	Reis-Pinheiro CA, Galati M, Summerville N, Lambrecht M.Using network analysis and machine learning to identify virus spread trends in COVID-19.Big Data Res. 2021; 25:100242.

[46]	Harweg T, Bachmann D, Weichert F.Agent-based simulation of pedestrian dynamics for exposure time estimation in epidemic risk assessment.J Public Health 2021; 31:221-228.

[47]	Leung NH.Transmissibility and transmission of respiratory viruses.Nat Rev Microbiol 2021; 19(8):528-545.

[48]	Madewell ZJ, Yang Y, Longini Jr IM, Halloran ME, Dean NE.Household transmission of SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and meta-analysis.JAMA Netw Open 2020; 3(12):e2031756.