PDF
(2337KB)
Abstract
Effective identification and assessment of various energy transition risks are essential for ensuring energy security. This study conducts a systematic review of the literature on energy transition risk assessment, with three principal objectives: ① establishing a standardized risk taxonomy, ② analyzing the characteristics of current assessment methodologies, and ③ identifying the priority research directions. First, energy transition risks are structured into two categories: implementation risks and consequential risks. Subsequently, assessment methodologies are categorized into five methodological groups: the indicator approach, probabilistic risk assessment approach, econometric approach, simulation approach, and hybrid approach. This analysis reveals a growing scholarly focus on consequential risks, particularly those affecting the energy system and economic system. The evolution of research shows a progression from macro-level analyses to micro-level investigations, accompanied by methodological advancement from simple indicator approach to the more sophisticated computational models. Future research may prioritize investigating multi-risk interactions and developing comprehensive assessment frameworks to address the complex risk landscape faced by diverse stakeholders in the energy transition.
Keywords
Energy transition
/
Risk assessment
/
Indicator
/
Simulation model
/
Probabilistic risk assessment
Cite this article
Download citation ▾
Peng Zhou, Guang-Xiao Wan, Wen Wen, Qing Zhu.
Energy Transition Risk Assessment: Concepts, Indicators, and Methodological Issues.
Engineering DOI:10.1016/j.eng.2025.10.009
| [1] |
Carley S, Evans TP, Konisky DM.Adaptation, culture, and the energy transition in American coal country.Energy Res Soc Sci 2018; 37:133-139.
|
| [2] |
Mukhtarov S, Azizov M, Kartal MT, Eynalov H.Catalyzing green transformation: mitigating oil price impact on CO2 emissions in Saudi Arabia via renewable energy transition.Environ Econ Policy Stud 2024; 2024:1-23.
|
| [3] |
Kartal MT, Shahbaz M, Taskin D, Depren SK, Ayhan F.How are energy transition and energy-related R&D investments effective in enabling decarbonization? Evidence from Nordic Countries by novel WLMC model.J Environ Manage 2024; 365:121664.
|
| [4] |
Kartal MT, Taskin D, Shahbaz M, Kirikkaleli D, Depren SK.Role of energy transition in easing energy security risk and decreasing CO2 emissions: disaggregated level evidence from the USA by quantile-based model.J Environ Manage 2024; 359:120971.
|
| [5] |
Johansson B.Security aspects of future renewable energy systems—a short overview.Energy 2013; 61:598-605.
|
| [6] |
Yang Y, Wang H, Loschel A, Zhou P.Energy transition toward carbon-neutrality in China: pathways, implications and uncertainties.Front Eng Manage 2022; 9(3):358-372.
|
| [7] |
Zhou P, Gao S, Lv Y, Zhao G.Energy transition management towards a low-carbon world.Front Eng Manage 2022; 9(3):499-503.
|
| [8] |
Cherp A, Jewell J.The three perspectives on energy security: intellectual history, disciplinary roots and the potential for integration.Curr Opin Environ Sustain 2011; 3(4):202-212.
|
| [9] |
Carley S, Evans TP, Graff M, Konisky DM.A framework for evaluating geographic disparities in energy transition vulnerability.Nat Energy 2018; 3(8):621-627.
|
| [10] |
Li FY, Zhang JX, Li XM.Energy security dilemma and energy transition policy in the context of climate change: a perspective from China.Energy Policy 2023; 181:113624.
|
| [11] |
Chester L.Conceptualising energy security and making explicit its polysemic nature.Energy Policy 2010; 38(2):887-895.
|
| [12] |
Memmott T, Carley S, Graff M, Konisky DM.Sociodemographic disparities in energy insecurity among low-income households before and during the Covid-19 pandemic.Nat Energy 2021; 6(2):186-193.
|
| [13] |
Sovacool BK.The low-carbon risk society: dilemmas of risk–risk tradeoffs in energy innovations, transitions, and climate policy.Risk Anal 2024; 45(1):78-107.
|
| [14] |
Curtin J, McInerney C, Gallachóir BO, Hickey C, Deane P, Deeney P.Quantifying stranding risk for fossil fuel assets and implications for renewable energy investment: a review of the literature.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2019; 116:109402.
|
| [15] |
.The effect of climate risks on the interactions between financial markets and energy companies. Nat.Energy 2022; 7:690-697.
|
| [16] |
Firdaus N, Mori A.Stranded assets and sustainable energy transition: a systematic and critical review of incumbents’ response.Energy Sustain Dev 2023; 73:76-86.
|
| [17] |
Zhou P, Lv Y, Wen W.The low-carbon transition of energy systems: a bibliometric review from an engineering management perspective.Engineering 2023; 29:147-158.
|
| [18] |
Sovacool BK.How long will it take? Conceptualizing the temporal dynamics of energy transitions.Energy Res Soc Sci 2016; 13:202-215.
|
| [19] |
Aven T, Renn O.Risk management and governance. Springer, Berlin (2010)
|
| [20] |
Hanger-Kopp S, Lieu J, Nikas A.Narratives of low-carbon transitions. Routledge, Abingdon (2019)
|
| [21] |
Smit B, Wandel J.Adaptation, adaptive capacity, and vulnerability.Glob Environ Change 2006; 16(3):282-292.
|
| [22] |
Roelich K, Dawson DA, Purnell P, Knoeri C, Revell R, Busch J, et al.Assessing the dynamic material criticality of infrastructure transitions: a case of low carbon electricity.Appl Energy 2014; 123:378-386.
|
| [23] |
Diego H, Noah F.Assessing county-level vulnerability to the energy transition in the United States using machine learning.Energy Res Soc Sci 2023; 100:103099.
|
| [24] |
Luderer G, Pietzcker RC, Carrara S, de HS Boer, Fujimori S, Johnson N, et al.Assessment of wind and solar power in global low-carbon energy scenarios: an introduction.Energy Econ 2017; 64:542-551.
|
| [25] |
Mo H, Li C, Liu N, Zhao B, Dong H, Liu H, et al.Energy storage systems for carbon neutrality: challenges and opportunities.Front Eng Manage 2025; 12(2):305-329.
|
| [26] |
Li SW, Pan ZL.Climate transition risk and bank performance: evidence from China.J Environ Manage 2022; 323:116275.
|
| [27] |
Ali SH, Giurco D, Arndt N, Nickless E, Brown G, Demetriades A, et al.Mineral supply for sustainable development requires resource governance.Nature 2017; 543(7645):367-372.
|
| [28] |
Karl TL.The paradox of plenty: oil booms and petro-states. University of California Press, Berkeley (1997)
|
| [29] |
Friedrichs J, Inderwildi OR.The carbon curse: are fuel rich countries doomed to high CO2 intensities?.Energy Policy 2013; 62:1356-1365.
|
| [30] |
Gabrielli L, Ruggeri AG, Scarpa M.Roadmap to a sustainable energy system: is uncertainty a major barrier to investments for building energy retrofit projects in wide city compartments?.Energies 2023; 16(11):4261.
|
| [31] |
Pata UK, Kartal MT, Depren KS.The role of information and communication technologies and energy-related research and development investments in energy transition: evidence from the United States of America by machine learning algorithm.Energy Technol 2024; 12(5):2301199.
|
| [32] |
Wu YN, Chu H, Xu CB.Risk assessment of wind–photovoltaic–hydrogen storage projects using an improved fuzzy synthetic evaluation approach based on cloud model: a case study in China.J Energy Storage 2021; 38:102580.
|
| [33] |
Dui H, Zeng Q, Xie M.Generative AI-based spatiotemporal resilience, green and low-carbon transformation strategy of smart renewable energy systems. Front Eng.
|
| [34] |
Chu W, Fan L, Zhou P.Examining the interactions of carbon, electricity, and natural gas markets.Front Eng Manage 2025; 12(3):543-557.
|
| [35] |
Xi Y, Huynh ANQ, Jiang YS, Hong YR.Energy transition concern: time-varying effect of climate policy uncertainty on renewables consumption.Technol Forecast Soc Change 2023; 192:122551.
|
| [36] |
Guetlein MC, Schleich J.Understanding citizen investment in renewable energy communities.Ecol Econ 2023; 211:107895.
|
| [37] |
Troendle T, Annaheim J, Hoppe J, Hanger-Kopp S, Patt A.Public preferences for phasing-out fossil fuels in the German building and transport sectors.Environ Res Commun 2023; 5(8):81001.
|
| [38] |
Ivanova D, Middlemiss L.Characterizing the energy use of disabled people in the European Union towards inclusion in the energy transition.Nat Energy 2021; 6(12):1188-1197.
|
| [39] |
Bustamante ML, Gaustad G.Challenges in assessment of clean energy supply chains based on byproduct minerals: a case study of tellurium use in thin film photovoltaics.Appl Energy 2014; 123:397-414.
|
| [40] |
Liang Y, Kleijn R, Tukker A, van E der Voet.Material requirements for low carbon energy technologies: a quantitative review.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2022; 161:112334.
|
| [41] |
Kosai S.Dynamic vulnerability in standalone hybrid renewable energy system.Energy Convers Manage 2019; 180:258-268.
|
| [42] |
McGlade C, Ekins P.The geographical distribution of fossil fuels unused when limiting global warming to 2 °C.Nature 2015; 517(7533):187-190.
|
| [43] |
Battiston S, Mandel A, Monasterolo I, Schütze F, Visentin G.A climate stress-test of the financial system.Nat Clim Chang 2017; 7(4):283-288.
|
| [44] |
Zhao LT, Li T, Zhang YJ, Wei YM.Measuring the price risk of energy portfolio with Copula-VaR model.Syst Eng Theory Pract 2015; 35(3):771-779.
|
| [45] |
Vermeulen R, Schets E, Lohuis M, Kölbl B, Jansen DJ, Heeringa W.The heat is on: a framework for measuring financial stress under disruptive energy transition scenarios.Ecol Econ 2021; 190:107205.
|
| [46] |
Lu YSY, Zhou XY, Simmons BA.Empirical analysis of Chinese overseas power plant investments: likelihood of suspensions and associated environmental risks.iScience 2023;26(8):107457.
|
| [47] |
Lizardo RA, Mollick AV.Oil price fluctuations and US dollar exchange rates.Energy Econ 2010; 32(2):399-408.
|
| [48] |
Raimi D, Carley S, Konisky D.Mapping county-level vulnerability to the energy transition in US fossil fuel communities.Sci Rep 2022; 12(1):15748.
|
| [49] |
Carley S, Konisky DM.The justice and equity implications of the clean energy transition.Nat Energy 2020; 5(8):569-577.
|
| [50] |
Xie LY, Hu X, Zhang XY, Zhang XB.Who suffers from energy poverty in household energy transition? Evidence from clean heating program in rural China.Energy Econ 2022; 106:105795.
|
| [51] |
Chishti MZ, Sinha A, Zaman U, Shahzad U.Exploring the dynamic connectedness among energy transition and its drivers: understanding the moderating role of global geopolitical risk.Energy Econ 2023; 119:106570.
|
| [52] |
Deng LF, Mah D, Cheung DMW, Lo KV.Civic activism and petition politics in energy transitions: discursive tactics, networking, and media mobilization in an anti-nuclear movement in China.Energy Res Soc Sci 2023; 95:102889.
|
| [53] |
Huber N, Hergert R, Price B, Zäch C, Hersperger A, Pütz M, et al.Renewable energy sources: conflicts and opportunities in a changing landscape.Reg Environ Change 2017; 17(4):1241-1255.
|
| [54] |
Wang SW, Su H, Chen CC, Tao W, Streets DG, Lu ZF, et al.Natural gas shortages during the “coal-to-gas” transition in China have caused a large redistribution of air pollution in winter 2017.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2020; 117(49):31018-31025.
|
| [55] |
Alvarado R, Ortiz C, Jim Nénez, Ochoa-Jim Dénez, Tillaguango B.Ecological footprint, air quality and research and development: the role of agriculture and international trade.J Clean Prod 2021; 288:125589.
|
| [56] |
Sun X, Hao H, Hartmann P, Liu ZW, Zhao FQ.Supply risks of lithium-ion battery materials: an entire supply chain estimation.Mater Today Energy 2019; 14:100347.
|
| [57] |
Castano-Rosa R, Okushima S.Prevalence of energy poverty in Japan: a comprehensive analysis of energy poverty vulnerabilities.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2021; 145:111006.
|
| [58] |
Crognier G, Tournebise P, Ruiz M, Panciatici P.Grid operation-based outage maintenance planning.Electr Power Syst Res 2021; 190:106682.
|
| [59] |
Lebre E, Stringer M, Svobodova K, Owen JR, Kemp D, Cote C, et al.The social and environmental complexities of extracting energy transition metals.Nat Commun 2020; 11(1):4823.
|
| [60] |
Chapman A, Shigetomi Y, Ohno H, McLellan B, Shinozaki A.Evaluating the global impact of low-carbon energy transitions on social equity.Environ Innov Soc Transit 2021; 40:332-347.
|
| [61] |
Zhou P, Delmas MA, Kohli A.Constructing meaningful environmental indices: a nonparametric frontier approach.J Environ Econ Manage 2017; 85:21-34.
|
| [62] |
Gnansounou E.Assessing the energy vulnerability: case of industrialised countries.Energy Policy 2008; 36(10):3734-3744.
|
| [63] |
Bongartz L, Shammugam S, Gervais E, Schlegl T.Multidimensional criticality assessment of metal requirements for lithium-ion batteries in electric vehicles and stationary storage applications in Germany by 2050.J Clean Prod 2021; 292(10):126056.
|
| [64] |
Li JH, Xu DY, Zhu YG.Global antimony supply risk assessment through the industry chain.Front Energy Res 2022; 10:1007260.
|
| [65] |
Zheng H, Zhou HJ.Probabilistic safety assessment. National Defense Industry Press, Beijing (2011)
|
| [66] |
Miranda MM, Raymond J, Dezayes C.Uncertainty and risk evaluation of deep geothermal energy source for heat production and electricity generation in remote northern regions.Energies 2020; 3(16):4221.
|
| [67] |
Flament G.Impact of the energy transition on long-term factor productivity.Struct Change Econ Dyn 2023; 66:393-406.
|
| [68] |
Yu HH, Chang KH, Hsu HW, Cuckler R.A Monte Carlo simulation-based decision support system for reliability analysis of Taiwan’s power system: framework and empirical study.Energy 2019; 178(1):252-262.
|
| [69] |
Mutani G, Santantonio S, Brunetta G, Caldarice O, Demichela M.An energy community for territorial resilience: measurement of the risk of an energy supply blackout.Energy Build 2021; 240:110906.
|
| [70] |
Le ST, Nguyen TN, Linforth S, Ngo TD.Safety investigation of hydrogen energy storage systems using quantitative risk assessment.Int J Hydrogen Energy 2023; 48(7):2861-2875.
|
| [71] |
Liu XD, Shahidehpour M, Cao YJ, Wu L, Liu X.Microgrid risk analysis considering the impact of cyber attacks on solar PV and ESS control systems.IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2017; 8(3):1330-1339.
|
| [72] |
Urbano EM, Martinez-Viol V, Kampouropoulos K, Romeral L.Risk assessment of energy investment in the industrial framework—uncertainty and sensitivity analysis for energy design and operation optimization.Energy 2022; 239:121943.
|
| [73] |
Chen LJ, Liu L, Zhou C, Xu XH.Weakness identification of integrated energy systems considering operation risk and resilience.Autom Electr Power Syst 2022; 46(6):48-57.
|
| [74] |
Chung JB, Kim ES.Public perception of energy transition in Korea: nuclear power, climate change, and party preference.Energy Policy 2018; 116:137-144.
|
| [75] |
Poruschi L, Ambrey CL.Energy justice, the built environment, and solar photovoltaic (PV) energy transitions in urban Australia: a dynamic panel data analysis.Energy Res Soc Sci 2019; 48:22-32.
|
| [76] |
Chico G, Clewer T, Midgley NG, Gallego-Anex P, Ramil-Rego P, Ferreiro J, et al.The extent of windfarm infrastructures on recognised European blanket bogs.Sci Rep 2023; 13(1):3919.
|
| [77] |
Su CW, Khan K, Umar M, Zhang WK.Does renewable energy redefine geopolitical risks?.Energy Policy 2021; 158:112566.
|
| [78] |
Ren XH, Li JY, He F, Lucey B.Impact of climate policy uncertainty on traditional energy and green markets: evidence from time-varying granger tests.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2023; 173:113058.
|
| [79] |
Xu YY.Will energy transitions impact financial systems?.Energy 2020; 194:116910.
|
| [80] |
Su CW, Pang LD, Qin M, Lobont OR, Umar M.The spillover effects among fossil fuel, renewables and carbon markets: evidence under the dual dilemma of climate change and energy crises.Energy 2023; 274:127304.
|
| [81] |
Sohag K, Sokolova Y, Vilamova S, Blueschke D.Volatility transmission from critical minerals prices to green investments.Resour Policy 2023; 82:103499.
|
| [82] |
van K der Wiel, Bloomfield HC, Lee RW, Stoop LP, Blackport R, Screen JA, et al.The influence of weather regimes on European renewable energy production and demand.Environ Res Lett 2019; 14(9):94010.
|
| [83] |
van DP Vuuren, van H Soest, Riahi K, Clarke L, Krey V, Kriegler E, et al.Carbon budgets and energy transition pathways.Environ Res Lett 2016; 11(7):75002.
|
| [84] |
Li FGN.Actors behaving badly: exploring the modelling of non-optimal behavior in energy transitions.Energy Strategy Reviews 2017; 15:57-71.
|
| [85] |
Ameli N, Dessens O, Winning M, Cronin J, Chenet H, Drummond P, et al.Higher cost of finance exacerbates a climate investment trap in developing economies.Nat Commun 2021; 12(1):4046.
|
| [86] |
De L la Pena, Guo R, Cao XJ, Ni XJ, Zhang W.Accelerating the energy transition to achieve carbon neutrality.Resour Conserv Recycling 2022; 177:105957.
|
| [87] |
Köberle AC, Shrimali G, Mittal S, Jindal A, Donovan C.Financial risks to coal value chain from a cost-conscious shift to renewables in India.Environ Res Lett 2022; 17(12):124002.
|
| [88] |
Liu TC, Pan WX, Zhu Z, Liu MY.Optimal risk operation for a coupled electricity and heat system considering different operation modes.IEEE Access 2021; 9:18831-18841.
|
| [89] |
Rasmussen KD, Wenzel H, Bangs C, Petavratzi E, Liu G.Platinum demand and potential bottlenecks in the global green transition: a dynamic material flow analysis.Environ Sci Technol 2019; 53(19):11541-11551.
|
| [90] |
Yang WX, Pan LY, Ding QY.Dynamic analysis of natural gas substitution for crude oil: scenario simulation and quantitative evaluation.Energy 2023; 282:128764.
|
| [91] |
Shimbar A, Ebrahimi BS.Political risk and valuation of renewable energy investments in developing countries.Renew Energy 2020; 145:1325-1333.
|
| [92] |
Wang XX, Wang AJ, Zhong WQ, Zhu DP, Wang CH.Analysis of international nickel flow based on the industrial chain.Resour Policy 2022; 77:102729.
|
| [93] |
Jiang L, Jiang H.Analysis of predictions considering mineral prices, residential energy, and environmental risk: evidence from the USA in COP 26 perspective.Resour Policy 2023; 82:103431.
|
| [94] |
Jackson A, Jackson T.Modelling energy transition risk: the impact of declining energy return on investment (EROI).Ecol Econ 2021; 185:107023.
|
| [95] |
Sharma T, Gallachóir BO, Rogan F.A new hybrid approach for evaluating technology risks and opportunities in the energy transition in Ireland.Environ Innov Soc Transit 2020; 35:429-444.
|
| [96] |
In SY, Manav B, Venereau CMA, Cruz LE, Weyant J.Climate-related financial risk assessment on energy infrastructure investments.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2022; 167:112689.
|
| [97] |
Ulpiani G, Vetters N.On the risks associated with transitioning to climate neutrality in Europe: a city perspective.Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2023; 183:113448.
|
| [98] |
Malthus TR.An essay on the principle of population. J. Johnson, London (1978)
|
| [99] |
Jevons WS.The coal question: an inquiry concerning the progress of the nation, and the probable exhaustion of our coal-mines. Macmillan, London (1865)
|
| [100] |
Arthur WB.Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events.Econ J 1989; 99(394):116-131.
|
