Steel–FRP Composite Bars and Closed-Type FRP Ties of Concrete Columns for Synergistic Enhancement in Axial–Flexural Stiffness, Strength, and Ductility

Shiwen Han; Gang Xiao; Chenghao Xu; Peicen Wang; Ao Zhou; Jing Yu; Jinping Ou

doi:10.1016/j.eng.2026.06.014

Engineering ›› :202606014 DOI: 10.1016/j.eng.2026.06.014

research-article

Steel–FRP Composite Bars and Closed-Type FRP Ties of Concrete Columns for Synergistic Enhancement in Axial–Flexural Stiffness, Strength, and Ductility

Author information +

History +

PDF (3878KB)

Abstract

Durable fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) bars are well-suited to marine infrastructure, particularly in applications involving seawater sea-sand concrete. However, their adoption is constrained by the low elastic modulus and brittle failure behavior of longitudinal FRP bars, as well as the inadequate confinement provided by conventional pultruded FRP ties. These limitations adversely affect serviceability (e.g., deflection and crack width), strength, and ductility of concrete columns subjected to axial–flexural loading. To address these challenges, this study proposes a novel hybrid reinforcement scheme for concrete columns, combining longitudinal steel–FRP composite bars (SFCBs) with closed-type FRP ties to enhance axial–flexural performance. An experimental program was conducted on hybrid longitudinal SFCB and FRP tie reinforced concrete (hybrid-RC) columns under various loading conditions to elucidate axial–flexural failure mechanisms, quantify the mechanical contribution of SFCBs, and evaluate the confinement behavior of closed-type FRP ties. Similar to conventional steel bars reinforced concrete columns, hybrid-RC columns exhibit compression-controlled and tension-controlled failure modes while achieving comparable serviceability, strength, and ductility. Notably, the post-yielding stiffness of SFCBs increases the load-carrying capacity by 11.3% under tension-controlled failure. In addition, closed-type FRP ties provide significantly improved confinement compared with pultruded FRP ties, resulting in substantial enhancement of axial–flexural capacity. An analytical model is further developed to predict axial–flexural failure modes and strength, incorporating the distinctive constitutive behavior of the hybrid reinforcement system and the experimentally observed failure mechanisms of hybrid-RC columns.

Keywords

Hybrid fiber-reinforced polymer–steel reinforcement / Concrete column / Axial–flexural behavior / Failure mode / Confinement mechanism

Cite this article

Download citation ▾

Shiwen Han, Gang Xiao, Chenghao Xu, Peicen Wang, Ao Zhou, Jing Yu, Jinping Ou. Steel–FRP Composite Bars and Closed-Type FRP Ties of Concrete Columns for Synergistic Enhancement in Axial–Flexural Stiffness, Strength, and Ductility. Engineering 202606014 DOI:10.1016/j.eng.2026.06.014

登录浏览全文

4963

注册一个新账户忘记密码

References

Publishing order | Descend order by publishing year | Descend order by cited within

[1]	Xiao J, Qiang C, Nanni A, Zhang K . Use of sea—sand and seawater in concrete construction: current status and future opportunities. Constr Build Mater 2017; 155:1101-11.

[2]	Shen W, Ran J, Fan L, Sun B, Zhang R . Investigation of macro—cell corrosion in rebar within cracked concrete beams under sustained loading conditions in the simulated marine environment. Constr Build Mater 2025; 468:140485.

[3]	Weng K, Zhu J, Huang B, Dai J, Chen J . Interfacial shear behavior between prefabricated strain—hardening ultra—high—performance concrete (SH—UHPC) and cast—in—place concrete. Eng Struct 2025; 325:119405.

[4]	Zhang K, Zhang Q, Xiao J . Durability of FRP bars and FRP bar reinforced seawater sea sand concrete structures in marine environments. Constr Build Mater 2022; 350:128898.

[5]	Zhao X, Zhang P, Zhang D, Zhao Q, Tuerxunmaimaiti Y . Prediction of interlaminar shear strength retention of FRP bars in marine concrete environments using XGBoost model. J Build Eng 2025; 105:112466.

[6]	Zhu J, Weng K, Huang B, Xu L, Dai J . Ultra—high—strength engineered cementitious composites (UHS—ECC) panel reinforced with FRP bar/grid: development and flexural performance. Eng Struct 2024; 302:117193.

[7]	Benmokrane B, Robert M, Mohamed HM, Ali AH, Cousin P . Durability assessment of glass FRP solid and hollow bars (rock bolts) for application in ground control of Jurong rock caverns in Singapore. J Compos Constr 2017; 21(3):06016002.

[8]	Huang B, Wu J, Yu J, Dai J, Leung CKY, Li VC . Seawater sea—sand engineered/strain—hardening cementitious composites (ECC/SHCC): assessment and modeling of crack characteristics. Cem Concr Res 2021; 140:106292.

[9]	Ebead U, Lau D, Lollini F, Nanni A, Suraneni P, Yu T . A review of recent advances in the science and technology of seawater—mixed concrete. Cem Concr Res 2022; 152:106666.

[10]	Han S, Zhong J, Yu Q, Yan L, Ou J . Sulfate resistance of eco—friendly and sulfate—resistant concrete using seawater sea—sand and high—ferrite Portland cement. Constr Build Mater 2021; 305:124753.

[11]	Han S, Zhong J, Ding W, Ou J . Strength, hydration, and microstructure of seawater sea—sand concrete using high—ferrite Portland cement. Constr Build Mater 2021; 295:123703.

[12]	Fang S, Luo Z, Fang Z, Huang D, Liu F, Xiong Z, et al. Concentric axial compressive performance of slender seawater sea—sand concrete square columns reinforced with hybrid FRP—steel bars and FRP interlocking multi—spirals. Constr Build Mater 2024; 450:138567.

[13]	Liao Q, Yu J, Dong F, Su Y, Yu K . FRP bars reinforced seawater sea—sand engineered cementitious composites beams with various salinities: shear behaviors and cost effectiveness. J Build Eng 2024; 83:108452.

[14]	Zhao Q, Zhao X, Zhang D, Duan L . Effects of exposure in seawater sea—sand concrete pore solution on fatigue performance of carbon FRP bars. Compos Sci Technol 2024; 247:110418.

[15]	American Concrete Institute (ACI) . ACI 440.1R—15: Guide for the design and construction of structural concrete reinforced with fiber—reinforced polymer (FRP) bars. ACI standard. Farmington Hills: ACI; 2015.

[16]	Canadian Standards Association (CSA) . CSA S806—12: Design and construction of building structures with fibre—reinforced polymers. CSA standard. Toronto: CSA; 2012.

[17]	American Concrete Institute (ACI) . ACI Code—440.11—22: Building code requirements for structural concrete reinforced with glass fiber—reinforced polymer (GFRP) bars—code and commentary. ACI standard. Farmington Hills: ACI; 2022.

[18]	Ge W, Zhu J, Ashour A, Yang Z, Cai X, Yao S, et al. Effect of chloride corrosion on eccentric—compression response of concrete columns reinforced with steel—FRP composite bars. J Compos Constr 2022; 26(4):04022042.

[19]	Ge W, Chen K, Guan Z, Ashour A, Lu W, Cao D . Eccentric compression behaviour of concrete columns reinforced with steel—FRP composite bars. Eng Struct 2021; 238:112240.

[20]	Bakouregui AS, Mohamed HM, Yahia A, Benmokrane B . Axial load—moment interaction diagram of full—scale circular LWSCC columns reinforced with BFRP and GFRP bars and spirals: experimental and theoretical investigations. Eng Struct 2021; 242:112538.

[21]	Elmessalami N, El Refai A, Abed F . Fiber—reinforced polymers bars for compression reinforcement: a promising alternative to steel bars. Constr Build Mater 2019; 209:725—37.

[22]	Ali MA, El—Salakawy E . Seismic performance of GFRP—reinforced concrete rectangular columns. J Compos Constr 2016; 20(3):04015074.

[23]	Yuan F, Chen M, Pan J . Experimental study on seismic behaviours of hybrid FRP—steel—reinforced ECC—concrete composite columns. Compos Pt B Eng 2019; 176:107272.

[24]	Nanni A, Henneke MJ, Okamoto T . Tensile properties of hybrid rods for concrete reinforcement. Constr Build Mater 1994; 8(1):27-34.

[25]	Han S, Zhou A, Ou J . Relationships between interfacial behavior and flexural performance of hybrid steel—FRP composite bars reinforced seawater sea—sand concrete beams. Compos Struct 2021; 277:114672.

[26]	Xiao G, Tan W, Mai P, Han S, Ou J . Pullout behavior of the steel—FRP composite bar with the anchor head made of the grout—filled steel tube. Compos Struct 2024; 341:118242.

[27]	Wu G, Wu Z, Luo Y, Sun Z, Hu X . Mechanical properties of steel—FRP composite bar under uniaxial and cyclic tensile loads. J Mater Civ Eng 2010; 22(10):1056-66.

[28]	Xiao G, Han S, Tan W, Ou J . Bond mechanism of grout sleeve splicing for steel—FRP composite bar and pullout behavior of the bar with anchor head in concrete. Constr Build Mater 2024; 450:138656.

[29]	Zhao D, Pan J, Zhou Y, Sui L, Ye Z . New types of steel—FRP composite bar with round steel bar inner core: mechanical properties and bonding performances in concrete. Constr Build Mater 2020; 242:118062.

[30]	Han S, Fan C, Zhou A, Ou J . Simplified implementation of equivalent and ductile performance for steel—FRP composite bars reinforced seawater sea—sand concrete beams: equal—stiffness design method. Eng Struct 2022; 266:114590.

[31]	Bai Y, Ma Q, Zhang Y, Jin X, Han S . Bond behavior and modeling of steel—FRP composite bars in engineered cementitious composites. Case Stud Const Mat 2024; 20:e03320.

[32]	Zhou Y, Zheng Y, Pan J, Sui L, Xing F, Sun H, et al. Experimental investigations on corrosion resistance of innovative steel—FRP composite bars using X—ray microcomputed tomography. Compos Pt B Eng 2019; 161:272-84.

[33]	Less T, Demir A, Sezen H . Structural performance and corrosion resistance of fiber reinforced polymer wrapped steel reinforcing bars. Constr Build Mater 2023; 366:130176.

[34]	Han S, Fan C, Zhou A, Ou J . Shear behavior of concrete beams reinforced with corrosion—resistant and ductile longitudinal steel—FRP composite bars and FRP stirrups. Eng Struct 2023; 278:115520.

[35]	Cai Y, Xie Z, Xiao S, Huang Z, Lin J, Guo Y, et al. An investigation of fatigue behavior and residual strength model of steel—GFRP composite bar. Compos Struct 2024; 327:117685.

[36]	Htet P, Chen W, Huang Z, Hao H . Flexural behaviour of hybrid fibre—reinforced recycled aggregate concrete beams with BFRP bars and steel—BFRP composite bars (SBCBs). Structures 2024; 69:107481.

[37]	Han S, Xiao G, Tan W, Mai P, Zhou A, Yu J, et al. Simplified equivalent design for novel hybrid steel—FRP composite bars and closed—type FRP stirrups reinforced seawater sea—sand concrete columns. Eng Struct 2025; 331:119995.

[38]	Han S, Zhou A, Fan C, Xiao G, Ou J . Axial—flexural performance of columns reinforced by steel—FRP composite bars and FRP ties. Compos Struct 2023; 322:117435.

[39]	Han S, Zhou A, Fan C, Xiao G, Ou J . Seawater sea—sand concrete columns using durable and ductile steel—FRP composite bars and FRP ties: a promising hybrid scheme for marine engineering. Eng Struct 2023; 294:116731.

[40]	Zhang Y, Bai Y, Han S, Milani G, Jin X . Seismic behavior of novel resilient and corrosion—resistant composite columns using strain—hardening engineered cementitious composites and steel—FRP composite bars. Eng Struct 2024; 305:117709.

[41]	Sun Z, Wu G, Zhang J, Zeng Y, Xiao W . Experimental study on concrete columns reinforced by hybrid steel—fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) bars under horizontal cyclic loading. Constr Build Mater 2017; 130:202—11.

[42]	Li P, Jin L, Chen W, Hao H, Du X . Numerical investigation on plastic hinge behavior of hybrid steel—FRP reinforced concrete columns. Eng Struct 2025; 322:119067.

[43]	Han S, Xiao G, Tan W, Mai P, Zhou A, Yu J, et al. Effect of tie parameters on strength and ductility of concrete columns reinforced with hybrid steel—fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composite bars. Eng Struct 2025; 322:119051.

[44]	Tang Y, Sun Z, Wu G, Wei Y . Compressive behavior of steel—FRP composite bars confined with low elastic modulus FRP spirals in concrete columns. J Compos Constr 2022; 26(5):04022058.

[45]	Tang Y, Sun Z, Wu G, Wei Y . Experimental study on cyclic behavior of SFCBs with different slenderness ratios. J Mater Civ Eng 2021; 33(8):04021204.

[46]	Dong H, Wang D, Wang Z, Sun Y . Axial compressive behavior of square concrete columns reinforced with innovative closed—type winding GFRP stirrups. Compos Struct 2018; 192:115-25.

[47]	Ahmed EA, El—Sayed AK, El—Salakawy E, Benmokrane B . Bend strength of FRP stirrups: comparison and evaluation of testing methods. J Compos Constr 2010; 14(1):3-10.

[48]	Xiao G, Tan W, Han S, Mai P, Ou J . Rectangular seawater sea—sand concrete columns using steel—FRP composite bars and closed—type winding FRP ties: axial behavior and confinement model. Compos Struct 2025; 354:118826.

[49]	Xiao G, Tan W, Han S, Mai P, Fan C, Ou J . Axial compression behavior of seawater sea—sand concrete columns reinforced with SFCBs and closed—type winding GFRP ties. Constr Build Mater 2024; 416:135147.

[50]	Lin G, Teng J . Three—dimensional finite—element analysis of FRP—confined circular concrete columns under eccentric loading. J Compos Constr 2017; 21(4):04017003.

[51]	Lin G, Zeng J, Teng J, Li L . Behavior of large—scale FRP—confined rectangular RC columns under eccentric compression. Eng Struct 2020; 216:110759.

[52]	American Concrete Institute (ACI) . ACI 440.3R—12: Guide test methods for fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composites for reinforcing or strengthening concrete and masonry structures. ACI standard. Farmington Hills: ACI; 2012.

[53]	Spadea S, Orr J, Ivanova K . Bend—strength of novel filament wound shear reinforcement. Compos Struct 2017; 176:244-53.

[54]	Ministry of Housing and Urban—Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China . GB/T 50010—2010: Standard for design of concrete structures. Chinese standard. Beijing: China Architecture and Building Press; 2024. Chinese.

[55]	Ministry of Housing and Urban—Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China. GB/T 50081—2019. Standard for test methods of concrete physical and mechanical properties. Chinese standard. Beijing:China Architecture and Building Press; 2019. Chinese.

[56]	Cai Z, Wang D, Wang Z . Full—scale seismic testing of concrete building columns reinforced with both steel and CFRP bars. Compos Struct 2017; 178:195-209.

[57]	Salah—Eldin A, Mohamed HM, Benmokrane B . Axial—flexural performance of high—strength—concrete bridge compression members reinforced with basalt—FRP bars and ties: experimental and theoretical investigation. J Bridge Eng 2019; 24(7):04019069.

[58]	Ge W, Zhang J, Cao D, Tu Y . Flexural behaviors of hybrid concrete beams reinforced with BFRP bars and steel bars. Constr Build Mater 2015; 87:28-37.

[59]	Ahmad A, Bahrami A, Alajarmeh O, Chairman N, Yaqub M . Investigation of circular hollow concrete columns reinforced with GFRP bars and spirals. Buildings 2023; 13(4):1056.

[60]	Ayoub M, Hasan HA, Sheikh MN, Hadi MNS. Effect of CFRP strip tie configurations on the behavior of GFRP reinforced concrete columns under different loading conditions. Structures 2024;69:107426.

[61]	Hadi MNS, Hasan HA, Sheikh MN . Experimental investigation of circular high—strength concrete columns reinforced with glass fiber—reinforced polymer bars and helices under different loading conditions. J Compos Constr 2017; 21(4):04017005.

[62]	Han S, Xiao G, Tan W, Zhou A, Yu J, Ou J . Effect of axial compression ratio on seismic behavior of hybrid FRP—steel reinforced concrete columns. Eng Struct 2025; 335:120325.