Journal Home Online First Current Issue Archive For Authors Journal Information 中文版

Engineering >> 2022, Volume 18, Issue 11 doi: 10.1016/j.eng.2022.05.010

State of Science: Why Does Rework Occur in Construction? What Are Its Consequences? And What Can be Done to Mitigate Its Occurrence?

a School of Civil and Mechanical Engineering, Curtin University, Perth, WA 6845, Australia
b School of Architecture and Built Environment, Deakin University Geelong Waterfront Campus, Geelong, VIC 3220, Australia
c School of Architecture and Built Environment, University Drive Callaghan, NSW 2308, Australia
d Department of Civil and Building Systems, Technische Universität Berlin, Berlin 13156, Germany

Received: 2022-03-28 Revised: 2022-05-17 Accepted: 2022-05-19 Available online: 2022-06-14

Next Previous

Abstract

There has been a wealth of research that has examined the nature of rework in construction. Progress toward addressing the rework problem has been limited—it still plagues practice, adversely impacting a project's performance. Almost all rework studies have focused on determining its proximal or root causes and therefore have overlooked the conditions that result from its manifestation. In filling this void, this paper draws upon our previous empirical studies, amongst others, to provide a much-needed theoretical framing to understand better why rework occurs, what its consequences are, and how it can be mitigated during construction. The theoretical framing we derive from our review provides construction organizations and their projects with a realization that the journey to mitigating rework begins with creating an error-mastery culture comprising authentic leadership, psychological safety, an errormanagement orientation, and resilience. We suggest that, once an error-mastery culture is established within construction organizations and their projects, they will be better positioned to realize the benefits of the techniques, tools, and technologies espoused to address rework, such as the Last Planner® and building information modeling. We also provide directions for future research and identify implications for practice so that strides toward rework mitigation in construction can be made. 

Figures

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

References

[ 1 ] CNN. Korean store owner, son sentenced for role in the collapse [Internet]. Atlanta: CNN; 1995 Dec 27 [cited 2022 Jan 26]. Available from: http://edition. cnn.com/WORLD/9512/skorea_store/sentencing/index.html. link1

[ 2 ] Riemer JW. Mistakes at work the social organization of error in building construction work. Soc Probl 1976;23(3):255–67. link1

[ 3 ] Petroski H. Success through failure: the paradox of design. New Jersey: Princeton Unversity Press; 2006. link1

[ 4 ] Love PED, Lopez R, Edwards DJ. Reviewing the past to learn in the future: making sense of design errors and failures in construction. Struct Infrastruct E 2013;9(7):657–88. link1

[ 5 ] Love PED, Edwards DJ, Smith J. Systemic project life cycle model for design error prevention. Struct Infrastruct E 2013;9(7):689–701. link1

[ 6 ] Love PED, Ika LA, Luo H, Zhou Y, Zhong B, Fang W. Rework, failure and unsafe behaviour: moving toward an error management mindset in construction. IEEE T Eng Manage. In press.

[ 7 ] Kolstad I, Wiig A. Is transparency the key to reducing corruption in resourcerich countries? World Dev 2009;37(3):521–32. link1

[ 8 ] Signor R, Love PED, Ika L. White-collar crimes: unearthing collusion in the procurement of public infrastructure. IEEE T Eng Manage. In press.

[ 9 ] García-Rodríguez MJ, Rodríguez-Montequín V, Pablo Ballesteros-Pérez P, Love PED, Signor R. Collusion detection in public procurement auctions with machine learning. Automat Constr 2022;133:104047. link1

[10] Robinson-Fayek A, Dissanayake M, Campero O. Developing a standard methodology for measuring and classifying construction fieldwork. Can J Civil Eng 2004;31(6):1077–89. link1

[11] Burati JL, Farrington J, Leadbetter WB. Causes of quality deviations in design and construction. J Constr Eng M 1992;118(1):34–49. link1

[12] Davis K, Ledbetter WD, Burati Jr JL. Measuring design and construction quality costs. J Constr Eng M 1989;115(3):385–400. link1

[13] Barber P, Sheath D, Tomkins C, Graves A. Quality failure costs in civil engineering projects. Int J Qual Reliab Manage 2000;17(4/5):479–92. link1

[14] Roberston C, Kasakove S. Pittsburgh bridge collapses hours before biden infrastructure visit [Internet]. New York City: New York Times; 2022 Jan 28 [cited 2022 Feb 1]. Available from: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/ us/pittsburgh-bridge-collapse-biden.html.

[15] Construction Industry Institute. The Field Rework Index: early warning for field rework and cost growth. Report No.: RS153-1. Austin, TX: The University of Texas at Austin; 2001.

[16] Josephson PE, Larrson B, Li H. Illustrative benchmarking rework and rework costs in the Swedish construction industry. J Manage Eng 2002;18(2):76–83. link1

[17] Construction Industry Institute. Making zero rework a reality. Report No.: RS 203-1. Austin, TX: The University of Texas at Austin; 2005.

[18] Hwang BG, Thomas SR, Hass CT, Caldas CH. Measuring the impact of rework on construction cost performance. J Constr Eng Mech 2009;135(3):187–98. link1

[19] Hwang BG, Zhao X, Goh KJ. Investigating the client related rework in building projects: the case of Singapore. Int J Proj Manag 2014;32(4):698–708. link1

[20] Ye G, Jin Z, Xia B, Skitmore M. Analyzing the causes for reworks in construction projects in China. J Manage Eng 2015;31(6):04014097. link1

[21] Construction Industry Institute. Achieving zero rework through effective supplier quality practices [Internet]. Austin, TX: Construction Industry Institute; 2019 [cited 2019 Nov 10]. Available from: https:// www.construction-institute.org/resources/knowledgebase/best-practices/ quality-management/topics/rt-308. link1

[22] Yap JBH, Chong JR, Skitmore RM, Lee WP. Rework causation that undermines safety performance during production in construction. J Constr Eng M 2020;146(9):04020106. link1

[23] Asadi R, Wilkinson S, Rotimi JOB. Towards contracting strategy usage for rework in construction projects: a comprehensive review. Construct Manag Econ 2021;39(12):953–71. link1

[24] Grag S, Misra S. Causal model for rework in building construction for developing countries. J Build Eng 2021;43:103180. link1

[25] Love PED, Smith J. Unpacking the ambiguity of rework in construction: making sense of the literature. Civ Eng Environ Syst 2018;35(1–4):180–203. link1

[26] Love PED, Matthews J, Fang W. Rework in construction: a focus on errors and violations. J Constr Eng M 2020;146(9):06020001. link1

[27] Love PED, Matthews J, Ika LA, Teo P, Fang W, Morrison J. From Quality-I to Quality-II: cultivating an error culture to support lean thinking and rework mitigation in projects. Prod Plann Control. In press.

[28] Love PED, Matthews J, Ika LA, Fang W. Error culture and its impact on rework: an exploration of norms and practices in a transport mega-project. DIBE 2022;10:100067.

[29] Love PED, Matthews J. Error mastery in alliance transport megaprojects. IEEE T Eng Manage. In press.

[30] Love PED, Ika LA, Matthews J, Fang W. Curbing poor quality in large-scale transport infrastructure projects. IEEE T Eng Manage. In press.

[31] Dekker S. The field guide to understanding human error. Farnham: Ashgate; 2006. link1

[32] Frese M, Keith N. Action errors, error management, and learning in organizations. Annu Rev Psychol 2015;66(1):661–87. link1

[33] Love PED, Matthews J. Quality, requisite imagination and resilience: managing risk and uncertainty in construction. Reliab Eng Syst Safe 2020;204:107172. link1

[34] Love PED, Smith J, Ackermann F, Irani Z. Making sense of rework and its unintended consequence in projects: the emergence of uncomfortable knowledge in practice. Int J Proj Manag 2019;37(3):501–16. link1

[35] Love PED, Smith J, Ackermann F, Irani Z. The praxis of stupidity: an explanation to understand the barriers to mitigating rework in construction. Prod Plan Control 2018;29(13):1112–25. link1

[36] Love PED. Creating mindfulness to learn from errors: enablers of rework containment and reduction in construction. DIBE 2020;1(1):100001. link1

[37] Van Dyck C, Frese M, Baer M, Sonnentag S. Organizational error management culture and its impact on performance: a two-study replication. J Appl Psychol 2005;90(6):1228–40. link1

[38] Love PED, Edwards DJ, Smith J. Rework causation: emergent insights and implications for research. J Constr Eng M 2016;142(6):04016010. link1

[39] Atkinson AR. The role of human error in construction defects. Struct Surv 1999;17(4):231–6. link1

[40] Atkinson AR. The pathology of building defects; a human error approach. Eng Constr Archit Ma 2002;9(1):53–61. link1

[41] Reason J. Human error. New York City: Cambridge University Press; 1990. link1

[42] Lei Z, Naveh E, Novikov Z. Errors in organizations: an integrative review via the level of analysis, temporal dynamism, and priority lenses. J Manage 2016;42(5):1315–43. link1

[43] Sasou K, Reason J. Reliability engineering and system safety. Reliab Eng Syst Safe 1999;65(1):1–9. link1

[44] Goodman PS, Ramanujam R, Carroll JS, Edmondson AC, Hofmann DA, Sutcliffe KM. Organizational errors: directions for future research. Res Organ Behav 2011;31:151–76. link1

[45] Busby J, Iszatt-White M. Rationalizing violation: ordered accounts of intentionality in the breaking of safety rules. Organ Stud 2016;37(1):35–53. link1

[46] Levinthal D, Rerup C. Crossing an apparent chasm: bridging mindful and lessmindful perspectives on organizational learning. Organ Sci 2006;17 (4):502–13. link1

[47] Mills AJ, Murgatroyd SJ. Organizational rules: a framework for understanding organizational action. Milton Keynes: Open University Press; 1991. link1

[48] Reason J, Parker D, Lawton R. Organizational controls and safety: the varieties of rule-related behavior. J Occup Organ Psych 1998;71(4):289–304. link1

[49] Pettit P. Rules, reasons, and norms. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2002. link1

[50] Love PED, Matthews J, Ika LA, Carey B, Fang W. The duality and paradoxical tensions of safety and quality: managing error in projects. IEEE T Eng Manage. In press.

[51] Das A, Pagell M, Behm M, Veltri A. Toward a theory of the linkages between safety and quality. J Oper Manag 2008;26(4):521–35. link1

[52] Busby JS, Hughes EJ. Projects, pathogens and incubation periods. Int J Proj Manag 2004;22(5):425–34. link1

[53] Love PED, Edwards DJ, Irani Z, Walker DHT. Project pathogens: the anatomy of omission errors in construction and resource engineering projects. IEEE T Eng Manage 2009;56(3):425–35. link1

[54] Love PED, Edwards DJ, Irani Z. Forensic project management: an exploratory examination of the causal behaviour of design-induced error. IEEE T Eng Manage 2008;55(2):234–47. link1

[55] Love PED, Cheung SO, Irani Z, Davis PR. Causal discovery and inference of project disputes. IEEE T Eng Manage 2011;58(3):400–11. link1

[56] Alvesson M, Spicer A. A stupidity-based theory of organizations. J Manage Stud 2012;49(7):1194–220. link1

[57] Dekker S. The problem of zero vision in work safety. Malaysian Labour Review 2013;8(1):25–36. link1

[58] Alvesson M, Sveningsson S. The good visions, the bad micro-management and the ugly ambiguity: contradictions of (non)leadership in a knowledgeintensive company. Organ Stud 2003;24(6):961–88. link1

[59] Westrum R. Technologies and society: the shaping of people and things social. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company; 1991. link1

[60] Wilczek F. Insanity [Internet]. Scientific American; 2015 Sep 23 [cited 2022 Feb 21]. Available from: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ einstein-s-parable-of-quantum-insanity/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CNa%C3%AFvet% C3%A9%20is%20doing%20the%20same,Question%3A%20 Finding%20Nature’s% 20Deep%20Design. link1

[61] Green SG, Welsh MA. Cybernetics and dependence: reframing the control concept. Acad Manage Rev 1988;13(2):287–301. link1

[62] Sitkin SB, Sutcliffe KM, Schroeder RG. Distinguishing control from learning in total quality management: a contingency perspective. Acad Manage Rev 1994;19(3):537–64. link1

[63] Yap JBH, Low PL, Wang C. Rework in Malaysian building construction: impacts, causes and potential solutions. J Eng Technol 2017;15(5):591–618. link1

[64] Love PED, Li H. Quantifying the causes and costs of rework in construction. Construct Manag Econ 2000;18(4):479–90. link1

[65] Jaafari A, Love PED. Quality costs in construction: case of Qom monorail project in Iran. J Constr Eng M 2013;139(9):1244–9. link1

[66] Love PED, Li H. Overcoming the problems associated with quality certification. Construct Manag Econ 2000;18(2):139–49. link1

[67] Josephson PE, Hammarlund Y. The causes and costs of defects in construction: a study of seven building projects. Automat Constr 1999;8(6):681–7. link1

[68] Love PED, Smith J, Ackermann F, Irani Z, Teo P. The costs of rework: insights from construction and opportunities for learning. Prod Plan Control 2018;29 (13):1082–95. link1

[69] Love PED. Auditing the indirect consequences of rework in construction: a case-based approach. Manag Audit J 2002;17(3):138–46. link1

[70] Love PED, Edwards DJ, Han S, Goh YM. Design error reduction: toward the effective utilization of building information modelling. Res Eng Des 2011;22 (3):173–87. link1

[71] Matthews J, Love PED, Porter S, Fang W. Smart data and business analytics: a theoretical framework for managing rework risks in mega-projects. Int J Inform Manage 2022;65:102495. link1

[72] Safe Work Australia. Key WHS statistics Australia [Internet]. Safe Work Australia; 2020 [cited 2022 Mar 3]. Available from: https://www. safeworkaustralia.gov.au/sites/default/files/202011/Key%20Work%20Health% 20and%20Safety%20Stats%202020.pdf. link1

[73] Love PED, Teo P, Smith J, Ackermann F, Zhou Y. The nature and severity of workplace injuries in construction: engendering operational benchmarking. Ergonomics 2019;62(10):1273–88. link1

[74] Love PED, Smith J, Ackermann F, Irani Z, Fang W, Ding LY, et al. Houston, we have a problem: a view of quality and safety tensions in projects. Prod Plan Control 2019;30(16):1354–65. link1

[75] Love PED, Teo P, Ackermann F, Smith J, Alexander J, Palaneeswaran E, et al. Reduce rework, improve safety: an empirical inquiry into the precursors to error in construction. Prod Plan Control 2018;29(5):353–66. link1

[76] Love PED, Teo P, Morrison J. Unearthing the nature and interplay of quality and safety in construction projects: an empirical study. Safety Sci 2018;103:270–9. link1

[77] Mahamid I. Impact of rework on material waste in building construction projects. Int J Construct Manag 2020;22(8):1500–7. link1

[78] Garty L. Asbestos found in $1.2b Perth Children’s Hospital, says WA Health Minister [Internet]. New York City: ABC News; 2016 Jul 14 [cited 2022 Mar 3]. Available from: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-07-14/asbestos-foundin-perth-childrens-hospital-roof-panels/7628108. link1

[79] Love PED, Ika LA. Making sense of hospital project misperformance: over budget, late, time and time again—why? And what can be done about it? Engineering. In press.

[80] PAC. PCH—a long awaiting period [Internet]. The Legislative Assembly of Parliament of Western Australia; 2018 [cited 2022 Mar 3]. Available from: https://www.parliament.wa.gov.au/parliament/commit.nsf/(Report+Lookup +by+Com+ID)/A5D4EC94C80CBC3048258258000A42FB/$file/60282652.pdf. link1

[81] Hollnagel E. Safer complex industrial environments. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2010. link1

[82] Hollnagel E. A tale of two safeties. Int Electron J Nucl Saf Simul 2013;4 (13):1–10. link1

[83] Westrum R. The study of information flow: a personal journey. Saf Sci 2014;67:58–63. link1

[84] Duhigg C. What Google learned from its quest to build the perfect team [Internet]. New York City: The New York Times Magazine; 2016 Feb 25 [cited 2022 Mar 4]. Available from: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/ 28/magazine/what-google-learned-from-its-quest-to-build-the-perfectteam.html. link1

[85] Burnison G. 7 years ago, Google set out to find what makes the ‘perfect’ team—and what they found shocked other researchers [Internet]. Fort Lee: CNBC; 2019 Feb 28 [cited 2022 Mar 4]. Available from: https://www. cnbc.com/2019/02/28/what-google-learned-in-its-quest-to-build-theperfect-team.html. link1

[86] Sacks R, Treckman M, Rozenfeld O. Visualization of workflow to support lean construction. J Constr Eng M 2009;135(2):1307–14. link1

[87] Sacks R, Kaner I, Eastman CM, Jeong YS. The Rosewood experiment—building information modeling and interoperability for architectural precast facades. Automat Constr 2010;19(4):419–32. link1

[88] Matthews J, Love PED, Mewburn J, Stobaus C, Ramanayaka C. Building information modelling in construction: insights from collaboration and change management perspectives. Prod Plan Control 2018;29(3):202–16. link1

[89] Sacks R, Koskela L, Dave B, Owen R. The interaction of lean and building information modeling in construction. J Constr Eng M 2010;139(9):968–80. link1

[90] Love PED, Matthews J, Zhou J. Is it too good to be true? Unearthing the benefits of disruptive technology. Int J Inform Manage 2020;52:102096. link1

[91] Sehaimi AO, Tzortzopoulos Fazenda P, Koskela L. Improving construction management practice with the Last Planner System: a case study. Eng Constr Archit Ma 2014;21(1):51–64. link1

[92] Servranckx T, Vanhoucke M, Aouam T. Practical application of reference class forecasting for cost and time estimations: identifying the properties of similarity. Eur J Oper Res 2021;295(3):1161–79. link1

[93] Egan R. Rethinking construction [Internet]. London: Department of Trade and Industry, HMSO; 1998 [cited 2022 Mar 5]. Available from: https://constructingexcellence.org.uk/rethinking-construction-the-eganreport/. link1

[94] Construct 21 [Internet]. Singapore: Ministry of Manpower and Ministry of National Development; 2000 [cited 2022 Jan 27]. Available from: https:// www.nas.gov.sg/archivesonline/data/pdfdoc/19991 02001.htm. link1

[95] CIC. Built Environment 2050: a report on our digital future. BIM 2050 [Internet]. CIC; 2014 [cited 2022 Mar 1]. Available from: https://cic.org.uk/ news/article.php?s=2014-09-01-cic-bim2050-group-publishes-builtenvironment-2050-reportAccessed. link1

[96] ACA. Changing the game: how Australia can achieve success in the new world of megaprojects [Internet]. ACA; 2017 [cited 2019 Jun 14]. Available from: https://www.constructors.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Changingthe-Game-Mega-Projects-Final1.pdf. link1

[97] ISSG. Building safety: Industry Safety Steering Group report for the Secretary of State [Internet]. London: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government; 2019 Jul 22 [cited 2022 Mar 8]. Available from: https://assets. publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/ attachment_data/file/932524/ISSG_report_final.pdf. link1

[98] Crook D, Tessler A. The cost of doing nothing report: prepared by BIS Oxford Economics for the Construction Industry Task Force [Internet]. 2021 May [cited 2022 Mar 8]. Available at: https://cfrd8-files.cfr.org/sites/default/file s/book_pdf/RA-RoadNowhere.pdf. link1

[99] Westrum R. A typology of organisational cultures. Qual Saf Health Care 2004;13(Suppl 2):ii22–7.

[100] Schein EH. Organizational culture and leadership. 4th ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2010. link1

[101] Bennett N, Lemoine J. What VUCA really means for you. Harv Bus Rev 2014;92(1/2):27. link1

[102] Dimitrova NG, Van Hooft EJA. In the eye of the beholder: leader error orientation, employee perception of leader and employee work-related outcomes. Acad Manag Discov 2021;7(4):530–53. link1

[103] Pope A. An essay on criticism [Internet]. [cited 2022 Mar 9]. Available from: http://www.public-library.uk/ebooks/33/23.pdf. link1

[104] Hofmann DA, Frese M. Errors in organizations. New York City: Routledge; 2011. link1

[105] Walker DHT, Rowlinson S. Routledge handbook of integrated project delivery. Abingdon: Routledge; 2020. link1

[106] Lloyd-walker B, Mills AJ, Walker DHT. Enabling construction innovation: the role of a no-blame culture as a collaboration behavioural driver in project alliances. Construct Manag Econ 2014;32(3):229–45. link1

[107] Matthews J, Love PED, Ika LA, Fang W. Error aversion or error management? Error culture at the sharp end of production. DIBE 2022;10:100074. link1

[108] Love PED, Smith J, Teo P. Putting into practice error management theory: unlearning and learning to manage action errors in construction. Appl Ergon 2018;69:104–11. link1

[109] Van Dyck C, Van Hooft E, De Gilder D, Liesveld L. Proximal antecedents and correlates of adopted error approach: a self-regulatory perspective. J Soc Psychol 2010;150(5):428–51. link1

[110] Avolio BJ, Gardner WL, Walumbwa F, Luthans F, May DR. Unlocking the mask: a look at the process by which authentic leaders impact follower attitudes and behaviors. Leadersh Q 2004;15(6):801–23. link1

[111] Jeffcott SA, Ibrahim JE, Cameron PA. Resilience in healthcare and clinical handover. Qual Saf Health Care 2009;18(4):256–60. link1

[112] Wildavsky A. Searching for safety. New Brunswick: Transaction Books; 1991. link1

[113] Hollnagel E, Woods D, Leveson NG. Resilience engineering: concepts and precepts. Aldershot: Ashgate; 2006. link1

[114] NTSB. Collapse of I-35W Highway Bridge Minneapolis, Minnesota August 1, 2007 [Internet]. Washington, DC: NTSB; 2008 Nov 14 [cited 2022 Mar 12]. Available from: https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/ Reports/HAR0803.pdf. link1

[115] IPA. The Pipeline Report: Australia and New Zealand infrastructure pipeline [Internet]. IPA; 2022 [cited 2022 Mar 12]. Available from: https://inform. infrastructure.org.au/webmail/576443/1184690572/49aa6a4b633652cc05 dd3792a55cb8c47b9c463151528f08e08eaeae4be356d6. link1

[116] Love PED, Ika LA, Matthews J, Fang W. Shared leadership, value and risks in large scale transport projects: re-calibrating procurement policy for postCOVID-19. Res Transp Econ 2021;90:100999. link1

[117] CIOB. Australian industry ‘‘on the brink of collapse,” warns John Holland after loss, global construction review [Internet]. CIOB; 2020 Mar 19 [cited 2022 Mar 12]. Available from: http://www.globalconstructionreview.com/ companies/australian-industry-brink-collapse-warns-john-holl/. link1

[118] Strauss A, Schatzman L, Ehrlich D, Bucher R, Sabshin M. The hospital and its negotiated order. In: Freidson E, editor. The hospital in modern society. New York City: Free Press; 1963. p. 147–69. link1

[119] Strauss A. Negotiations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 1978. link1

[120] Ingardi I, Meyer C, Vrdin P. Narrative genres in error and failure stories: a multimodal study of f**kup nights videos. Acad Manag Discov 2021;7 (4):482–508. link1

[121] Love PED, Smith J. Error management: implications for construction. Constr Innov 2016;16(4):418–24. link1

Related Research